|
 |
 |
|
|










|
bIRTH:
iMPRINTS |
Birth:
The Foundational Imprint
The following paper presents a discussion
of the influence of birth on the psyche. |
Psychotherapy
Curriculum
Vitae
Workshops
Lectures

|
| |
THE
GENESIS OF BIRTH TRAUMA |
| PRENATAL
INFLUENCE ON BIRTH TRAUMA |
| BASIC
PERINATAL MATRICES |
|
First
Basic Perinatal Matrix (BPM I) "Symbiotic Unity" |
| Second
Basic Perinatal Matrix (BPM II) "Antagonism" |
| Third
Basic Perinatal Matrix (BPM III) "Synergism" |
| Fourth
Basic Perinatal Matrix (BPM IV) "Separation" |
| THE
MEDICALIZATION OF BIRTH |
| THE
EMERGENCE OF BIRTH MEMORIES |
| BIRTH
AS A HAZARDOUS TRANSITION |
| ONLY
TRAUMATIC BIRTHS ARE TRAUMATIC |
| POSITIVE
PRE- & PERINATAL EXPERIENCES |
| BENIGN
BIRTH INFLUENCES |
| LOSS
AT BIRTH |
| FOETAL
AWARENESS OF EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT |
| GLOBAL
FEELINGS OF BIRTH |
| THE
LEGACY OF BIRTH |
| ELABORATION
OF THE IMPRINT |
| AVERTING
AN IMPRINT FROM TRAUMA AT BIRTH |
| ENVIRONMENTAL
FAMILIARITY |
| INJURY
OR ILLNESS AS BIRTH TRAUMA REINFORCEMENT |
| CHILDHOOD
TRAUMA AS REINFORCEMENT |
| PHYSICAL
TRAUMA AT BIRTH |
| SOMATIC
EXPRESSION OF BIRTH MEMORY |
| CRANIAL
BIRTH TRAUMA |
| BIRTH
TRAUMA TO THE LUNGS |
| SOMATIC
METAPHORS |
| BIRTH
SCHEMAS |
| BIRTH
SCHEMAS IN ART |
| REPATTERNING
PHYSICAL SCHEMAS |
| LABOUR
LIE |
| TRANSMARGINAL
EXPERIENCE OF BIRTH |
| BIRTH
RAGE |
| BODY
MEMORY METAPHORS OF BIRTH |
| LIFE
SCRIPTS OF BIRTH |
| BIRTH
AS PROTOTYPE FOR TRANSITIONS |
| RESOLVING
THE FEELINGS OF BIRTH |
| RESOLVING
CORE ISSUES |
| |
| THE
GENESIS OF BIRTH TRAUMA
As early as 1949, predating the vast anecdotal
accounts of the "birth psychotherapies," Nandor
Fodor (1949) gave an interesting genesis of the psychology
of the trauma of birth when he wrote: |
I hold the following principles
of pre-natal psychology to be basic:
1. In our present day life,
birth is traumatic in almost every instance.
2. The longer the labour, the
more serious the physical complication, the greater the
trauma of birth.
3. The intensity of the trauma
of birth is proportionate to the shocks or injuries which
the child suffers during labour or immediately following
delivery.
4. The love and care which the
child receives immediately after birth is a decisive factor
in the persistence and intensity of the traumatic pressure.
(33)
|
| The
perceptiveness of these concise criteria of the trauma of
birth are remarkable in light of the later research of Emerson
(1987), Janov (1983) and others. The early insights of Fodor
have been confirmed by tens of thousands of accounts from
breathwork, hypnotherapy, and deep feeling regressive therapies
(Grof 1975, 1985; Laing 1976; Feher, 1980; Verny, 1981; Janov,
1983; Noble, 1993)
Swartley (1978) worked with birth regression
through deep feeling abreaction and concluded from observing
thousands of birth regressions, in North America and Europe
that the: |
Degree of Trauma: Correlates positively
with the degree of mutual cooperation between mother and
foetus which is determined by many factors, such as:
1. Degree to which mother (i) desired
and (ii) planned pregnancy.
2. First delivery or not. In general,
the first child suffers most trauma for physical and emotional
reasons. The mother is usually most frightened during the
first delivery. Any trauma during the mother's birth is
usually "triggered" most by the birth of her first
child.
3. Size of mother's pelvic bone
(smaller the pelvis, more traumatic the birth).
4. Size of the child's head and
shoulders, umbilical cord, etc. (larger the head and shoulders,
the more traumatic).
5. Health of the mother, as influenced
by diet, addictions, amount of sleep and rest, etc.
6. Age of mother (can be too young
or too old).
7. Drugs administered by obstetrician
which inhibit participation of the mother (most of which
pass through to inhibit participation of the foetus).
8. Age of foetus (premature, full
term or postmature).
9. Disease(s) in mother (heart
disease, diabetes, anaemia, etc.).
10. Foetal position - head first
usually least traumatic; a breech (buttocks first) is usually
most traumatic. (p. 39)
|
In
this passage Swartley posits birth trauma as being related
primarily to the physical characteristics of the foetal head
and the structure of the pelvis and cervix at the time of
birth; and to a degree, to the emotional relationship of mother
and child. Fodor (1949) and Swartley are largely in agreement
with each other, theoretically, on the overall nature of the
trauma of birth. In Fodor's passage, he places significant
emphasis on the complications of labour and the reception
given the newborn following birth.
Any theoretic model of the psyche can only
be viewed as guide, or landmark for reference, and never should
be used as a rigid formula describing all people
or most people. In warning of the need for caution
in generalizing, or even worse dogmatizing, psychological
theories and interpretations of pre- and perinatal concerns
Verny (1994) recounts a Greek myth: |
A highway robber, called Prokrustes who would offer wayfarers
hospitality under the condition that they fit exactly his
bed. Since most travellers were either too short or too
long, he stretched the short ones and cut the legs off the
tall ones, killing them in the process. I am afraid that
interpretations based on rigid and unsubstantiated theories
are Procrustean in nature, violating the individual's psyche.
They tend to produce mindless conformity instead of real
understanding. (p. 168)
|
| Enthusiastically
fitting clients into the theories of the clinician can do
much for the ego of the therapist, but the expected client
compliance does little for the person seeking emotional health,
and may even be harmful if it robs clients of their own reality.
Feher (1980) suggests we need to avoid,
"making dogmatic statements: rather it must be seen that
we are describing the patterns we have observed, and attempting
to initiate imaginative thinking about the subject" (p.
164). After experiencing a particular birth condition a person
may acquire feelings, life scripts or behaviours described
in this section or they may not. There may be personal resilience,
or other more positive life experiences which offset the stress
of the trauma of birth: in addition, infants and young children
can, in their own creative wisdom, find resourceful means
of interpreting life events which are unique to that person.
The stones cast in the ripples of birth are not islands unto
themselves. |
 |
| PRENATAL
INFLUENCE ON BIRTH TRAUMA |
| Birth
issues in the psyche can be compounded with other life stresses
which may have occurred in the nine months before birth or
during the years of childhood. The more painful, and the earlier
that prenatal trauma first occurs, the more likely there is
to be a clustering of prenatal and birth traumas. In fact,
in medical births, perinatal issues often come in clusters
due to a series of traumas at birth, or in response to a spiralling
of mishaps during birth.
Earlier prenatal trauma may make an infant
more vulnerable to traumas during the rigours of birth, or
set the foundations for a predisposition in the child to interpreting
birth's severe stresses as trauma. Research of Barnett (1987)
revealed, "of the 76 patients with a negative birth experience
the surprising finding is that 48 (63%) had a prenatal negative
experience responsible for, or contributing to, the negative
birth feelings" (p. 202).
Various global birth feelings such as a
sense of a lack of connection or sense of betrayal at birth
can be particularly predominant when birth was preceded by
significant prenatal stresses or traumas. Findeisen (1993)
points to a few prenatal and other early wounds which may
combine with the cataclysm of birth to haunt the person with
a continuing sense of loss and disconnection:
Adoption, abortion, drug abuse, miscarriage,
infant or maternal death, mental and physical illness, emotional
rejection, and even anaesthesia have the potential to create
life-long feelings of separation and loss. Healing these
feelings requires that professionals acknowledge the causal
relations between a human being's first imprints and later
behaviour and development. (p. 65)
The psychology of birth can be significantly
influenced by events and conditions of the prenatal period.
This current work only sparsely addresses some of those prenatal
issues, which will be discussed more thoroughly in a volume
in preparation. The vast majority of therapeutic work in pre
and perinatal psychology clinical practice and psychological
theory has been done on the psychological issues surrounding
birth. Perhaps an extensive area of discovery about human
psychology will be the emotional foundations which result
from the long genesis in the womb.
To develop an understanding of this area,
more clinicians and clients will have to journey into the
darkness and rhythm of embryonic waters. From my experiences
of personally working with art and clinically working with
art, I suspect that drawing, painting and sculpture will be
important aids in the exploration and cartography of the prenatal
realm. At times, that which can not initially be spoken or
cognitively understood can be expressed in art. Art activity
can help identify when and where a trauma occurred, how the
trauma was perceived and interpreted, and in what way that
prenatal trauma may have layered with subsequent psychological
material. Verny (1994) suggests that a, "systematic study
of the [pre- and perinatal] material that emerges in the course
of psychotherapy is facilitated by identifying it with a specific
stage of pre- and perinatal development (p. 161)." He
proposes: |
to use a Gestation Model in which I
arbitrarily divide the first phase of life into six stages
as follows:
A. Primary Germ Cell Stage
B. Conception Stage
C. Oviduct Stage
D. Implantation Stage
E. Uterine Stage
F. Labour and Birth Stage (p. 166)
|
| Laing
(1976), Mott (1960; 1964) and Peerbolt (1975) have written
about the psychological constructs associated with Verny's
first four stages of the Gestation Model. These prebirth developmental
stages and points of possible physical and psychological peril
introduce psychological foundation stones significantly before
the extraordinary transition of birth.
In psychotherapy, particularly when employing art activity,
it can be beneficial to acknowledge and listen to clients
when they journey in the realms of birth or the womb. If the
client has the courage to venture into the rhythm of the preverbal
darkness the least the clinician can do is empathetically
observe, acknowledge and follow. It would be considerate of
the clinician to become familiar with the pre- and perinatal
realm or to acknowledge the client's experience and refer
to a specialist for this piece of work. In many cases, pre
and perinatal issues can be resolved by using good therapeutic
practice and following the path of the client. Generally clients,
when respected for their own pacing and inner wisdom, will
only journey deeply into those areas they have the strength
to face and are ready to deal with.
Some of the most comprehensive theoretical work on the last
two stages which Verny's model outlines has been developed
by Grof (1975, 1985) with his theories of Basic Perinatal
Matrices (BPM). I will discuss Grof's work in this area next. |
 |
BASIC
PERINATAL MATRICES
Grof organizes perinatal experiences and
their corresponding interweave in the fabric of the unconscious
into four levels of "Basic Perinatal Matrices (BPM)"
(p. 100). These perinatal matrices correlate with conditions
and periods of the transition of birth, and according to Grof
correlate with some innate structures which interpret human
experience. Perinatally: |
BPM I is associated with: Symbiotic Unity
and the realm of the womb;
BPM II is associated with: Antagonism
and the period of heavy labour when the cervix is still
closed and the prenate is being crushed and contained and
is not moving;
BPM III is associated with: Synergism
and the transition of moving through the birth canal on
dilated cervix;
BPM IV is associated with: Separation
and being released from the birth canal and includes material
from conditions immediately after birth.
|
 |
| BPM I |
BPM II
|
BPM III |
BPM IV |
|
| Illustration
from Grof (1985) |
| Birth
is a fluid experience and there is in fact, no clear delineation
point between the various stages of labour (May-Gaskin, 1977).
These defined stages are used as a model for considering the
influences of birth; Grof (1985) states that these divisions
are organized as "hypothetical dynamic matrices governing
the processes related to the perinatal level of the unconscious"
(p. 100). Many clinicians and theorists have found Grof's cartography
of the landscape of birth within the human psyche to be quite
useful (deMause, 1982a; Lake, 1979; Swartley, 1978). However
if it were used clinically as a rigid portrait of the actual
experience and phenomenon of most births, the BPM model would
tend to negate the individual's experience. Grof (1985) suggests
that: |
In addition to having specific emotional and psychosomatic
content of their own, these matrices also function as organizing
principles for material from other levels of the unconscious.
From the biographical level, elements of important COEX
systems dealing with physical abuse and violation, threat,
separation, pain, or suffocation are closely related to
specifics aspects of BPM.... the connecting link is the
same quality of emotions or physical sensations, and/or
similarity of circumstances. (p. 101)
|
When
the conditions of life recapitulate the conditions of perinatal
traumatic material, the psyche forms associative bridges linking
seemingly similar events and feelings. There are many ways
in which later life experience can be associated with perinatal
conditions. These are likely to be in the context of: similarity
to environmental conditions, sensation in any of the senses,
type of feeling or depth of affect; whether the conditions
are non-verbal or associated with change or transition; or
if the external origin of the stress is coming from another
individual one who is acting out from his or her perinatal
matrix.
Organizing perinatal experience into four
matrices provides a structure for relating the influence and
interrelatedness of the perinatal realm with other life experience.
When the individual's language elaborations are highly reflective
of a sense of, "Not getting anywhere, being suffocated
by the road blocks, and will die before anything moves on
this" it may be worthy to explore material from BPM II.
Whereas, metaphors of, "I've almost got it, I just need
a little more time, I can barely breathe but I see the light
ahead," may be indicative of material associated with
BPM III. Verny (1994) suggests that therapist should, "familiarize
themselves with the relationship between certain symptom clusters
and perinatal matrices. I think this knowledge will improve
considerably their ability to help clients with problems that
originated at birth" (p. 180)
A person who indicates manifestations of
a particular BPM matrix in the therapy setting can do so as
the consequence of many different provocations and/or background
causes. To name a few: it can mean that this is the particular
stage of birth which created the primary trauma of birth;
or this was the particular condition(s) of birth which was
repeatedly reinforced by childhood circumstance or parenting
styles; or there is something in the current life which is
triggering or recapitulating a specific matrix; or that matrix
and its issues are the ones that are surfacing in the client's
natural progression of healing.
The therapeutic process can unfold along
the lines of the Basic Perinatal Matrices, particularly when
current issues are intricately interwoven with birth material,
significant life changes or personal transformations, the
breaking down or building up of relationships, new beginnings
or endings; or psychological material associated with crises,
transitions and transformations. The working through of any
of these conditions can be found to follow the stages of the
Basic Perinatal Matrices. Transitions or crisis can be viewed
as unfolding in the order of the matrices starting from the
first, BPM I, and moving through each to the last, BPM IV;
or, more rarely, a person or situation may follow the categories
in reverse order, moving from BPM IV back to BPM I. When trauma
is overwhelming at a number of stages, the progression can
go from the most recent to the earliest; or from the least
severe stage to the one most difficult to face. These two
scenarios are probably an artifact of the process of moving
down psychologically into material in increasingly deeper
layers of the psyche.
Some people live out of, and are
in effect reliving, one particular Basic Perinatal Matrix,
or they interpret or respond to certain life conditions or
circumstances from one particular matrix or another. It is
helpful to clinically identify and observing the particular
Basic Perinatal Matrix a person is immediately associated
with. This can allow therapist and client to understand and
put into context some of the feelings, metaphors and issues
the person is grappling with. The person can be more clearly
supported in what they are moving through and can be assisted
with resolution. Also therapist and client can anticipate
and accept the next stages of therapeutic healing.
People may experience a hopeless no-exit
crisis after a time of feeling everything is perfect. This
conflict can be understood as a stage in the progression of
healing. There is movement from BPM I to BPM II. The crisis
is the surfacing of birth material from the Antagonism of
BPM II after having connected with the Symbiotic Unity of
BPM I. Client and therapist can realize that the person is
not decompensating or digressing after a positive plateau,
rather the person feeling the no-exit hopelessness is moving
through the next stage in healing the effects of a traumatic
birth. The person can be helped to understand the nature of
their feeling of being pushed down and not getting anywhere.
BPM II material may arise in association with a present situation
which legitimately reflects the BPM II conditions. As an artifact
of the birth issues which are surfacing, the intensity of
the feelings are out of context with the current problem.
It is in this sense that the original birth experience needs
to be connected with and resolved.
Some clients find it highly useful to
work with a model and language framework of birth matrices
because it allows them a context to understand and organize
their experience. Some people classically identify with the
patterns and categories, or their birth work aligns with the
various stages. For others the model does not make sense,
feels too clinical, stereotyping or in some other way stifling.
Many find that when their life history
and life patterns are viewed as a larger whole, one specific
matrix and its elements and issues stand out slightly more
than the others, but that they can see their issues, feelings
and response patterns in several of the matrices.
Not all clinicians who work with birth
material will find a divisional model of the birth process
a helpful tool. For example Feher (1980) views:
pregnancy and birth as a continuous
process, amenable to detailed phenomenological description,
and full of "fringe facts" (events which cannot
be precisely measured), both emotional and psychological.
We thus oppose the more conventional view of birth as discrete,
with entirely separable phases. (p. 61)
The theory or approach which is "right"
is the one which works for and is in harmony with both client
and therapist. Following below each Basic Perinatal Matrix
will be discussed in greater detail. |
 |
First
Basic Perinatal Matrix (BPM I) "Symbiotic Unity"
During BPM I, the intra-uterine experience
of symbiotic unity prior to the onset of delivery the person
largely feels security, protection, satisfaction and cosmic
unity. Grof, like deMause (1982a) and others, does recognize
that, although in utero conditions may be highly ideal, for
various reasons there may be experiences of a toxic or threatening
womb. The first perinatal matrix is associated with the period
of time in the womb before birth. Grof (1985) describes: |
The biological basis of this matrix
is the experience of the original symbiotic unity of the
fetus with the maternal organism at the time of intrauterine
existence. During episodes
of undisturbed life in the womb, the
conditions of the child can be close to ideal. However,
a variety of factors of physical, chemical, biological,
and
psychological nature can seriously
interfere with this state. Also, during late stages of pregnancy,
the situations my become less favourable because of the
size of the child, of increasing mechanical constraint,
or of the relative insufficiency of the placenta.
Pleasant and unpleasant intrauterine
memories can be experienced in their concrete biological
form. (p. 102)
|
Grof
allows this matrix to incorporate the entire prenatal period.
The prenatal period is a long interval to be influenced by
the environment. The prenatal period is not just the passage
of nine months of the same kind of life experience, but consists
of the many extraordinary developments and changes which occur
during conception, implantation, embryonic development and
fetal growth. It is more likely that over the long duration
of development and diversity of experience before being born
that the conditions and psychological issues of the in utero
period are far more complex than one prenatal stage would
imply. Verny's theoretical model of a five prenatal gestational
stages during the time in the womb is perhaps more in keeping
with the great diversity of personal experiences reported
in the prenatal period. |
| However,
Grof (1985) employed his theoretical framework of BPM matrices
to primarily examine the "characteristics of the death-rebirth
processes" (p. 100). As a stage specifically related to
birth itself and to transition and metamorphosis, BPM I would
be associated with conditions which transformation leaves behind;
whether that be the in utero pleasure and an all providing womb,
or the good old days and all was well before... (fill in the
blank). Grof (1985) describes, "associated memories from
postnatal life," for birth matrix one as: |

Figure 5BV: Aspect of Happiness (Second
Fetal Form); from Naumburg (1950). |
Situations from later life in which important needs are
satisfied, such as happy moments from infancy and childhood
(good mothering, play with peers, harmonious periods in
the family, etc.), fulfilling love, romances; trips or vacations
in beautiful natural settings; exposure to artistic creations
of high aesthetic value; swimming in the ocean and clear
lakes, etc. (p. 104)
|
| The
myth of in utero paradise can make it appear that BPM I is primarily
characterized by cosmic bliss. But the journey over the gestational
period appears to be a distressing time for some, and certain
conditions of Verny's first four gestational stages -- Primary
Germ Cell Stage, Conception Stage, Oviduct Stage and Implantation
Stage -- can be associated with significant maternal, family
issues, and life threatening risks. In addition deMause (1982a)
presents a case for a toxic environment during the final trimester
of the prenatal period. |
|
It is likely that for many the womb provides varying degrees
of symbiotic union, and some interludes of being enveloped
by an all nurturing and all protecting world. According to
the cartography of Basic Perinatal Matrixes, BPM I would intersect
with later life experiences of pleasure, relaxation, beautiful
and natural scenery and art. In this light it may make sense
that natalistic expression has such a powerful ability to
return clients to womb experience. Artistically connecting
with BPM I can provide a means of identifying and resolving
prenatal distress. Additionally there may be significant strengths
and fundamental foundations of connectedness or creativity
which are reconnected with and/or further enhanced by BPM
I natalistic activity. |

Figure 5C: Happiness (Fourth Fetal Form);
From Naumburg (1950). |
|
Second
Basic Perinatal Matrix (BPM II) "Antagonism"
BPM II, the second matrix, "Antagonism",
is the reaction to the contractions in the first clinical
stage of birth. It is here that the person feels the onset
of the pressure of birth which may be accompanied by feelings
of physical torment, claustrophobia, and hopelessness often
mixed with guilt. BPM II may be associated with feelings of
wanting to go back in order to seek relief from threat or
despair. Of BPM II, Grof (1985) forwards: |
This experiential pattern is
related to the very onset of biological delivery and its
first clinical stage. Here the original equilibrium of the
intrauterine existence is disturbed, first by alarming chemical
signals and then by muscular contractions. When this stage
fully develops, the fetus is periodically constricted by
uterine spasms; the cervix is closed and the way out is
not yet available.
As in the previous matrix, this biological
situation can be relived in a rather concrete and realistic
fashion. The symbolic concomitant of the onset of delivery
is the experience of cosmic engulfment. It involves overwhelming
feelings of increasing anxiety and awareness of an imminent
vital threat. (p. 111)
|
The
infant locked in this stage of birth is experiencing physical
pain and risk, with the feeling there is no way out. There
may be a sense of betrayal by a nurturing universe and the
mother. Lake (1979) portrays, "The mother for the first
time, having supported the foetus for nine months, is now
the aggressor, the relentless force that is against you, that
seems determined to kill or destroy you" (p. 9). The
tragedy the infant is locked in appears unresolvable, with
death a possible outcome. If death does not come, death may
be desired because of the overwhelming physical and emotional
pain (Roedding, 1993).
Lake (1981) notes: |

Firgure 5D: Prenatal threats my produce
life_long feelings of wanting to hide or retreat from a perceived
toxicity or danger "out there" -- a woumb surround
drawing from natalistic therapy. |
Although for most people the process
of birth may be tough but tolerable, for some it can be
devastating. Cataclysmic muscular convulsions turn a peaceful
haven into a crushing hell. This "no-exit" phase,
before the cervix begins to open, can last for some hours.
The next phase, of travel through the pelvis, is at best
an energetic struggle, at worst a brain-destroying, suffocating,
twisting, tearing, crushing torture, in which the will to
live may be extinguished and a longing to die take its place.
(pp. 18-19)
|
| BPM
II has many of the associated attributes of psychological shock,
what Findeisen (1993) and Lake (1981) refer to as transmarginal
stress. Natalistic art images from BPM II can have a high degree
of morbid and hopeless affect and imagery. Art work which expresses
helpless torment and symbolic images in hellish scenes can be
an attempt to convey the no-win entrapment of BPM II. Imagery
of BPM II can be: vices; closed and constricting circles; repressive
prisons and dungeons with no exit; airplanes, cars or trains
that crash with no hope for survival; walls that are impervious
and have no holes, exits or doors. If there are doors, they
are locked or bolted; caves have no passageways, or they are
securely blocked. Grof (1975) refers to art works which express
the powerful feeling of BPM II: |

Figure 5E: Trauma early in birth can create feelings of not
wanting to go forward, wanting to go back to better places,
difficulties in getting started, engulfment and stuck feelings
of in a no exit hell. |
The paintings appearing in this context include Hieronymus
Bosch's pictures of nightmarish and bizarre creatures, James
Ensor's gloomy world of skeletons and morbid masquerades,
Francisco Goya's images of the horrors of the war, the apocalyptic
visions of Salvador Dali and other surrealists, and numerous
famous representation of hell and the Last Judgement. (p.120)
|
| Colours
of BPM II art are often of doom and darkness and likely to have
a quality of fear. Grof (1985) suggests: |
The symbolic counterpart of a fully developed first clinical
stage of delivery is the experiences of no exit or hell.
It involves a sense of being stuck, caged, or trapped in
a claustrophobic, nightmarish world and experiencing incredible
psychological and physical tortures. This situation is usually
absolutely unbearable and appears to be endless and hopeless.
The individual loses the sense of linear time and can see
no possible end to this torment or any form of escape from
it. (p. 112)
|
Some
people who endlessly make hopeless and tormented pictures
may be helped with resolution of their perpetual torture by
identifying the perinatal content and emotion in the work.
Extreme BPM II material may need cathartic expression along
with producing the art works. Encouraging the artist to employ
non-verbal sounds and spontaneous body movements along with
either creating the art, or during a break from the art activity,
can often quickly bring on a full blown rebirth abreaction.
A reclining posture, focusing on body sensation and deep breathing,
can further facilitate pre-verbal catharsis.
Later traumatic childhood abuse which
is psychologically overwhelming would likely become entwined
with the material of BPM II. The art work of BPM II is likely
to contain elements of both birth and incidence of child abuse
or childhood operation, severe illness or near death injuries.
Grof (1985) concurs: |

Figure 5F: "At worst a brain-Destroying suffocation, twisting
tearing, crushing torture"; Goya From Campbell (1974). |
"As far as the organizing function of BPM II is concerned,
it attacks COEX systems with memories of situations in which
the passive and helpless individual is subjected to, and
victimized by, an overwhelming destructive force with no
chance of escaping" (p. 113).
|
As
a response to life threatening or overwhelming and transmarginal
childhood conditions, the psyche returns to where learning
about coping with this depth of pain previously occurred --
in the hopelessness, betrayal, and life threats of this stage
of birth. It is possible that in the safety of a supportive
childhood environment the elements of BPM II will not predominate
as feelings and issues in a person's life, and will remain
dormant unless a significant childhood trauma or loss occurs. |

Figure 5G: A no exit hell is created as the infant is engulped
by the birth canal and maybe strangled by the umbilical cord;
from Hogarth (1980). |
| For
some, the conditions of BPM II are forever present or just under
the surface in anticipation of life's next wound. The material
of BPM II stays alive and active when the life threat and helplessness
was particularly severe at this stage of birth; when a person
experienced significant prenatal stresses and transmarginal
conditions; when the childhood environment validated and reinforced
the despairing conditions of birth. Grof (1985) describes, "associated
memories from postnatal life," for BPM II as: |
Situations endangering survival and body integrity (war
experiences, accidents, injuries, operations, painful diseases,
near drowning, episodes of suffocation, imprisonment, brainwashing,
and illegal interrogation, physical abuse, etc.); severe
psychological traumatization (emotional deprivation, rejection,
threatening situations, oppressive family atmosphere, ridicule
and humilation, etc.). (p. 104)
|
BPM
II sets in place feelings that nothing is moving, and that
there is no way out. Regressing to and resolving to BPM II
can be a cataclysmic experience. The feelings and memories
of this stage of birth can be painful and overwhelming, even
though they may be decades old. Due to the intensity of the
feelings there can be a commensurate degree of resistance.
As a result of the sense of "no-exit" and "hopelessness"
in the origins of these birth feelings the feelings themselves
become interwoven with the resistance. "Nothing is happening,"
"I can't get through this," "There is no use
trying" are feelings and issues of the original experience,
feelings and issues of BPM II. Grof (1985) allows that: |

Figure 5H: "I am dying," "Nothing I do can help"
"This is getting nowhere;" from Huxley (1979) |
While under the influence of this matrix, the subject is
also selectively blinded to anything positive in the world
and in his or her own existence. Agonizing feelings of metaphysical
loneliness, helplessness, hopelessness, inferiority, existential
despair, and guilt are standard constituents of this matrix.
(pp. 112-113)
|
In
therapy people struggling with this matrix see no way out
of their suffering. They may not even want to try, or may
appeal to, or even demand of, the therapist to pull them out
of their suffering -- as the forceps-wielding obstetrician
did in the original birth.
During the period of extended despair
associated with BPM II, the client may see no use in doing
anything to work through the feelings. The psychological issues
that BPM II is presenting are the very hopelessness the client
feels, but the nature of their very presentation -- as it
is hopeless -- puts up a wall to their resolution. Unfortunately
while the issues of this matrix are surfacing, the very feelings
that need to be expressed are used as the rationale for not
facing or resolving them.
The clinician needs to be sensitive to
this paradox and assist the client in recognizing the degree
of helpless no-win despair which is being carried as an old
unresolved feeling. For the therapist to try to rescue the
client and present rationales for hope, change and optimism
can rob the client of facing and resolving these buried feelings.
Conversely to offer no direction or assistance denies the
client the support necessary to work through some very overwhelming
feelings. This whole conflict becomes particularly difficult
for the clinician when the client is deeply locked into the
feelings.
Natalistic art activity can provide a
recourse to this paradox. The art work can concretely express
the torture, despair and helplessness. Although the images
and affect of the art can say, "I am dying," "Nothing
I do can help," "This is getting nowhere,"
the art activity is doing something real and active. It is
a statement from the darkened time, when no one saw; now the
perinatal plight is witnessed by the adult self and an empathetic
therapist. The art production is permanent and can be returned
to by the artist or other compassionate witnesses. The art
provides hope where there was a despair, and the art allows
the artist to convey the true sense of hopelessness which
BPM II instills. |
 |
Third
Basic Perinatal Matrix (BPM III) "Synergism"
In BPM III, one is engaged in and moving
through the birth canal. This "Synergism" has purpose
and energy, but for some it also has some of the deepest feelings
of threats of suffocation, crushing trauma directly to the
head, and a life/death struggle for survival. Clyne (1977)
defines the second stage of labour which is Grof's third birth
matrix (BPM III), "as the stage of expulsion of the baby,
from the time that the cervix is fully dilated until it is
born" (p. 171). Lake (1979) postulates that: |
In the third matrix the process is saying, "Now here
you really get moving." The cervix opens and the foetus
and womb elongate, the head is beginning to be pushed and
moulded to get into the inlet of the pelvis, with its long
axis from side to side. Then it has to rotate because the
long axis of the outlet is from front to back. We see, in
primal work, this rotation taking place, again. (p. 11)
|
| In
terms of global direction BPM II is the dialectic of BPM II.
The struggle of wanting relief through going back, changes to
now struggling to move on and move forward to escape their torment
and despair. |
For
mother and child a significant transition occurs when the
baby finally begins to descend through the birth canal in
BPM III. The barrier begins to weaken through the opening
of the cervix; the moulding of the infant's cranial plates,
the force of the contractions and the efforts of the infant
can now work together. An opening has occurred in a previously
impenetrable wall. Verny (1981) says, "Now, suddenly,
his entire body is being squeezed and rubbed. His skin is
being directly stimulated for the very first time" (p.
120); and later continues, "The caressing and massaging
the baby receives as it passes down the birth canal represent
a first encounter with sensuality and, however diffuse or
unfocused the quality of that feeling, it leaves a permanent
mark" (p. 121). The massage of birth is a paradox in
that together with the stimulation there is also pain (Verny,
1981). |

Figure 5I: A significant transition occurs when the baby finally
begins to descend through the birth canal; from Huxley (1979). |
Grof
(1985) suggests that even though there may be pain, "The
situation here does not seem hopeless and the subject is not
helpless. He or she is actively involved and has the feeling
that the suffering has a definite direction and goal"
(p. 119). Where before there was a "no-exit" crisis,
now even slight movement intimates the plausibility of struggling
for survival. Grof (1985) sees that: |
Many important aspects of this
complex experiential matrix can be understood from its association
with the second clinical stage of biological delivery. In
this stage, the uterine contractions continue, but unlike
in the previous stage, the cervix is now dilated and allows
a gradual propulsion of the fetus through the birth canal.
This involves an enormous struggle for survival, crushing
mechanical pressures, and often a high degree of anoxia
and suffocation.
The birth is now proceeding, but the
prenate has likely exhausted much of its reserves. Furthermore,
there are still significant tribulations which will be encountered
in the actual slow and crushing movement through the cervical
passage. The second stage of labour can last from five minutes
to hours (Clyne 1977). Verny (1981) asserts, "The uterine
contractions exert a great deal of pressure on his body,
especially on his head, neck and shoulders" (p. 121).
Grof (1985) points out, "the enormity of the forces
involved in this stage of birth. The frail head of the child
is wedged into the narrow pelvic opening by the power of
uterine contractions that oscillate between 50 and 100 pounds"
(p. 116).
|
Art
work of BPM III can have clearly defined openings, there may
be images of light, bright circular areas or an area of the
drawing which focuses on the contrast of bright and dark.
BPM III can be the focus of journey art, art of passage ways
and caves with openings. In its more threatening negative
expression BPM III can be represented by suffocation, ropes
around the neck, crushing blows to the head or constricting
bands around the body or head. Walls and circles have openings;
caves, prisons, tunnels, or dungeons will have exits and passages
ways and if there are doors or windows they will be open or
unlocked, although they may be frightfully small and tight.
A light ahead or an area of birth colouring signifies the
way out. BPM III drawings can have imagery contrasting darkness
and brightness, despair and hope, pressure and release. The
art work might convey that the struggle is ongoing, but there
is the sense of movement and eventual possibility of resolution,
which can engender imagery expressing relief and hope. |

Figure 5J: At birth the infant realizes, "I am Dying'"
"Nothing I do can help," "I am getting nowhere;"
from Jacobs (1979) |
| BPM
III art, like that stage of birth, is a paradox of dialectic.
There is suffering, yet victory is near. Grof (1985) states,
while in contact with BPM III material: |
the subject does not play exclusively the role of a helpless
victim. He is observer and can at the same time identify
with both sides to the point that it might be difficult
to distinguish whether he is the aggressor or the victim.
While the no-exit situation involves sheer suffering, the
experience of the death-rebirth struggle represents the
borderline between agony and ecstasy and the fusion of birth.
It seems appropriate it identify this type of experience
as "volcanic ecstasy" in contrast to the "oceanic
ecstasy" of the cosmic union. (p. 120)
|
| In
conquering the near peril of birth, the neonate confronts a
death and rebirth in the very process of being born. The interpretation
of this life challenge is greatly influenced by the quality
of connection which the prenate is able to engender with the
mother or others in the birthing environment. Lake, (1979) notes: |
The life and death struggle of this third matrix may give
the child the sense of being confident on its own, or in
synergy with the mother, or the sense of being the victim
of her contradictory forces and ambivalence. "Her uterus
shoves me forward but then she holds her perineum perilously
tight. Why can't she decide what she wants with me."
That, too, can last a lifetime.(p. 12)
|
| At
this stage of birth the infant is in motion through the birth
canal. BPM III material is associated with movement and extremes
of emotion at the time of birth and in later life. Art work
about this stage of birth can be energized and active, with
a sense of movement and spatial transition. Grof (1985) describes,
"associated memories from postnatal life," for birth
matrix three as: |
Struggle, fights, and adventurous activities (active attacks
in battles and revolutions, experiences in military service,
rough airplane flights, cruises on stormy ocean, hazardous
car driving, boxing); highly sensual memories (carnivals,
amusements parks and nightclubs, wild parties, sexual orgies
etc.); childhood observations of adult sexual activities;
experiences of seduction and rape; in females, delivering
of their own children. (p. 104)
|
| Art
work depicting these images may be representative of these life
experiences or can be symbolic or metaphorical expressions of
traumatic birth material. |
 |
Fourth
Basic Perinatal Matrix (BPM IV) "Separation"
After the previous perilous struggle the
light ahead is encountered in the fourth matrix, "Separation",
as the child leaves the womb, experiences relaxation, relief,
but also the termination of the union with the mother and
an end of feelings of annihilation. Grof (1985) has noted,
"A classic symbol of the transition from BPM III to BPM
IV is the legendary bird, the Phoenix, whose old form dies
in fire and new form rises from the ashes and soars toward
the sun" (p. 119). The metamorphosis of the butterfly,
the upward passages of angels or the hero walking out of the
belly of the serpent or whale can also be images of BPM IV.
As outlined by Grof (1985), BPM IV: |
Figure 5K:
There is a light ahead as there is an end in sight to the arduous
journey; Grof (1980) |
is meaningfully related to the third clinical stage of
delivery, the actual birth of the child. In this final stage,
the agonizing process of the birth struggle comes to an
end; the propulsion through the birth canal culminates and
the extreme build-up of pain, tension, and sexual arousal
is followed by a sudden relief and relaxation. (p. 122)
|
| Initially
this matrix expresses release from the arduous, yet finally
victorious journey. This relief should be met with nurturance
and protection. Unfortunately the post birth medical drama makes
short work of the infant's sense of accomplishment and freedom
from pain in the birth canal. |
|
Once outside the womb the infant quickly
learns the medical authorities really mean business. The cord
is cut before breathing has adapted to a new environment.
The indignity of being hung upside down and slapped about
until one screams is terrifying, humiliating, confusing and
painful. The infant is greeted with painful intrusions through
suctioning the nose and throat. Cold air and bright lights
are followed by burning drops in the eyes, being laid on a
painfully cold and hard metal scales, heel lancing and for
males painful genital mutilation. Abandonment to a nursery
that can only be experienced as isolation, and rejection interrupts
what should be victory, relief, recovery and bonding. Grof
(1985) states: |

Figure 5L: The Phoenix "rises from the ashes and soars
toward the sun;" from Grof (1985) |
The child is born and, after a long period of darkness,
faces for the first time the intense light of the day (or
the operating room). After the umbilical cord is cut, the
physical separation from the mother has been completed and
the child begins its new existence as an anatomically independent
individual.
As with other matrices, some of the experiences belonging
here seem to represent an accurate replay of the actual
biological events involved in birth, as well as specific
obstetric intervention. For obvious reasons, this aspect
of BPM IV is much richer than the concrete elements experienced
in the context of the other matrices. The specific details
of the relived material are also easier to verify. They
involve specifics of the birth mechanism, types of anaesthesia
use, nature of manual or instrumental intervention, and
details of postnatal experience and care. (pp. 122-123)
|
The
negative aspects of BPM IV can be represented in images of
uprooted trees, trees cut in half, knives and cutting, pictures
of people dangling upside down, eyes, noses or mouths stinging
or being penetrated. For males there can be images representing
a penis which has been painfully mutilated. As a result of
multiple invasions and penetrations there may be expressions
of resentment of authorities. Images of nursing babies may
be positive or negative.
In celebration of victory, particularly
victory over grave crisis or cataclysm connects with the material
of BPM IV. Manic or euphoric expressions of art can resonate
with energy from this stage of birth. Grof (1985) describes,
"associated memories from postnatal life," for birth
matrix four as: |

Figure 5M: Typically in modern birth isolation and rejection
interrupts what should be victory, relief, recovery and bonding;
from Huxley (1979) |
Fortuitous escape from dangerous situations (end of war
or revolution, survival of an accident or operation); overcoming
of severe obstacles by active effort; episodes of strain
and hard struggle resulting in a marked success; natural
scenes (beginning of spring, end of an ocean storm, sunrise,
etc.). (p. 104)
|
|
Grof's basic perinatal matrixes give one
model for examining the experience and influences of birth.
Most writers in Pre- and perinatal psychology have found Grof's
framework a useful tool for theoretical reflection and structure.
Works of art have been particularly useful in describing and
illustrating theories employing Grof's Basic Perinatal matrices
(deMause, 1982a; English, 1985; Grof, 1985; Lawson, 1987;
Irving, 1988; Janus, 1991).
Because art work has so effectively been
useful to illustrate and communicate the Basic Perinatal Matrix
model, exploring therapeutic natalism with the BPM Model may
also be beneficial. |
 |
THE
MEDICALIZATION OF BIRTH
Both the complications during labour and
the treatment following birth have been radically altered
from nature by modern obstetrics. Medical routines and procedures
have become major factors adding to the trauma of birth, thereby
compounding and deepening its long term psychological wounds.
Many of the physically intrusive medical interventions of
birth are also psychologically threatening and their damage
potentially, can be compounded. In addition to the difficult
passage of the birth canal there may have been other assaults
to the infant such as forceps, the intense and erratic contractions
of inducted labour, fetal monitor wires painfully screwed
into the scalp, and drugs. Not an overt assault but perhaps
even more psychologically invasive and undermining is the
general lack of acknowledgment, support or encouragement of
the powerful primal mother-infant flow, the cooperation and
knowingness of birth. In the twentieth century, The Century
of Violence, Birth has been made more painful and psychologically
unsensitive for infants.
Fodor (1949) did not know that in the
second half of the twentieth century the psychological plight
of the perinate would actually worsen in the majority of births.
The proliferation of medical interventions has created more
complications, not fewer, during hospital birth; in a spiral
these birth complications have been medically responded to
with additional complication-prone interventions. The solution
for physicians who could not control the primal nature of
vaginal birth seemed to be to reject the powerful biological,
psychological and spiritual flow of birth.
As the ultimate statement of medical authority
and power, children on a scale never before seen began entering
the arms of parents through radical and invasive surgery.
Caesarian sections became the passageway for twenty-five percent
of births. In some hospitals ninety percent of births were
surgical. For some doctors and social classes, ninety-nine
percent of births were celebrated by the sterile and shiny
knife of major surgery. In an attempt to avoid those regrettable
incidents where nature might reign, C-sections were scheduled
two weeks before expected term.
As the ultimate statement of medical authority
and power, children on a scale never before seen began entering
the arms of parents through radical and invasive surgery.
Caesarian sections became the passageway for twenty-five percent
of births. In some hospitals ninety percent of births were
surgical. For some doctors and social classes, ninety-nine
percent of births were celebrated by the sterile and shiny
knife of major surgery. In an attempt to avoid those regrettable
incidents where nature might reign, C-sections were scheduled
two weeks before expected term.
Fodor suggests that a positive human reception
following birth might ameliorate some of the psychological
traumas of labour and indeed, the work of Emerson (1987) and
Klaus and Kennell (1976) supports this position. Unfortunately,
more often than not, the immediate post-birth medical technological
theatre does not attempt to soothe and nurture the psychological
distress of the human infant, rather physical and emotional
pain is the prescription of the hour. After surviving the
cataclysm of the crushing and suffocating passageway of birth,
the already fragile and overwhelmed infant is further subjected
to cold air, bright lights, early cutting of the cord, being
hung upside-down by the ankles, abrasive rubbing of the skin,
burning drops in the eyes, painful heal lancing, mutilation
of the genitals and extended deprivation of maternal contact.
With all these insensitive and cruel acts being inflicted
on the infant there is little opportunity for psychological
recovery. More likely, any conclusions and interpretations
of the previous experience as being a negative trauma will
be further validated and become more deeply entrenched as
core feelings, world views and life patterns.
Opportunity for the mother or father to
soothe, comfort and reassure the newborn is undermined by
the authority of the neonatal nursery, which sends the message,
"The medical authorities know best the needs of your
child." Rather than continual touch, stroking and sharing
glances, the newborn, in her infant-sized plastic petri dish
is occasionally observed without touch for signs of her biological
functions and stability.
It would seem that the director, writers
and principle actors in the theatre of modern obstetrics studied
Fodor's portrait of the genesis of the trauma of birth and
decided to routinely produce the ultimate perinatal tragedy.
As in the theatre, the non-speaking bit part actors do not
really die, but unlike theatre they are tragically destined
to continually relive the initial scenes of their first dramatic
rite of passage.
A majority of children and adults born
during the medicalization of childbirth are likely to be found
to have some degree of birth trauma. It is likely that a good
portion, or even as Houston (1993) figures, "most of
the people alive today" (p. 53), are natally wounded.
Noble (1993) points out that, "In 1988, 40 percent of
births were unwanted" (p. 246). It is likely that a good
number of adults seeking psychotherapy were unwanted pregnancies,
and their "normal" births were all but normal (Liedloff,
1985). Noble (1993) further reports, "Less than 10 percent
of women give birth naturally, without drugs or instruments"
(p. 229). Research by Verny (1981) showed a significant percent
of his adult subjects report pre- and perinatal stresses:
|
As might be expected of any group in psychotherapy, my
subjects tended to have highly charged prenatal and birth
histories: 66 percent described their mothers as being under
a lot of stress during pregnancy: 47 percent said she was
seriously unhappy. Still 55 percent said their mothers had
been looking forward to motherhood, as opposed to 45 percent
who reported a negative attitude. The ratios for fathers
were only slightly narrower: 51 percent said their fathers
wanted a child, 49 percent, that they had not.... Only 16
percent reported having been put to their mothers's breast
after birth.
The results from the subjective section were more enlightening.
Peacefulness was the most commonly reported womb feeling
(43 percent), but it was followed very closely by anxiety
(41 percent). There was a high incidence of traumatic birth
memories. Over 60 percent of the subjects said they had
remembered feeling suffocated during birth, and well over
40 percent reported having either head, neck or shoulder
pain. (p. 70)
|
| There
are common birth feelings and behaviour patterns associated
with modern medical birth which a variety of therapists have
collectively noted in the literature on pre- and perinatal psychology.
Khamsi (1987), in research with therapy clients who had undergone
birth regressions, found: |
Several emotions were common during birth feelings. Most
widespread were variations of fear (e.g., fear of death,
inability to breathe, lack of control, sense of danger),
and anger (e.g., frustration, irritability). Also common
were feelings of anxiety, desperation, discomfort, helplessness,
hopelessness, loneliness, neediness, powerlessness, sadness,
and vulnerability, and impressions of being abandoned, unloved,
and unwanted. (pp. 53-54)
|
| These
birth feelings came up during adult therapeutic regressions.
They are the feelings of the infant at birth, and are often
filtered through the lenses of
further childhood and adult wounds. |
 |
THE
EMERGENCE OF BIRTH MEMORIES
Decades old birth and womb feelings which
were previously repressed can spontaneously arise for adults
during psychotherapy, while dreaming, in response to creating
art work, during meditation, as an effect of psychotropic
drugs, in psychotic episodes and in various altered states
of consciousness. Occasionally, some adults have sensory or
emotional flashbacks to birth or womb experiences, particularly
in the time periods after the previously mentioned activities.
Also, during times of significant life changes, or when in
crisis, the outward expressions of birth trauma may become
highlighted or more animated. Psychologically, the person
is returning to a foundational crisis to assist them through
the current life ordeal. Once the door to the realm of birth
consciousness is open, it often continues to beg for resolution.
The individual is sometimes then more consciously presented
with overwhelming birth feelings which had previously unconsciously
ruled parts of life. |

Figure 5M: There are individuals who report always having a
conscious memory of birth or womb events -- a sculpture from
a natalistic therapy workshop. |
| When
the effects of birth trauma do begin to surface they can often
be expressed in dreams, life fears and language elaborations.
After bringing birth feelings and memories into consciousness
a client reported to Janov (1983): |
Since I first began to experience birth feelings, I have
become aware of further symbolism that seems to be related
to it:
- I frequently dream about being enclosed in some underground
canal system which is too narrow to get through. Often I
cannot move my feet....
- Being awake, I fear small rooms and spaces in which
I can get trapped....
- My language is filled with phrases such as "I'm
stuck", "I feel trapped," "There's no
way out" and so on. (p. 68)
|
| At
times, while people are in the grip of discovering and working
through birth expressions, their manifestations can seem to
be everywhere: in relationships, in social conventions, in art
and architecture -- in the fears, angers and motivations of
daily living. For periods, the person may become obsessively
aware of the ghosts of birth which cast their shadows on personality,
society and culture. Fortunately, the pendulum of awareness
most often swings back to a balance. The person retains the
ability to see the legacy of birth on adult life, but is not
quite so taken up with the "Ah Ha" of discovery. This
period of immersion in, and commitment to, an issue or subject
can be helpful in the process of psychological understanding
and resolution and many forms of intellectual learning and integration
(Moustakas, 1990). |

Figure 5O A significant psychophysiological transition occurs
at birth as the realm or oceanic existence is replaced throgh
a cataclysmic upheaval -- the physical separation is total and
permanent. |
| There
are rare cases of people who report always having had access
to memories of birth or womb conditions. It is difficult to
tell how many, because all the ones I have spoken directly with
have also said they rarely or never shared the memories because
of past experiences of both lay and professional denial and
even ridicule of their claimed presence of early memories. One
young man I interviewed had extensive womb and premature nursery
memories. Another, a middle-aged high school teacher, had always
remembered the doctor's strange green mask he had seen as a
newborn at birth. My seven-year-old son was talking with some
friends at school about their hospital births. He quipped, "Maybe
that is why so many people want to be doctors -- wearing those
masks they are the first person most people see." |
 |
BIRTH
AS A HAZARDOUS TRANSITION
It must be placed into psychological perspective
that the real degree of distress at birth is reflected in
the fact that, according to Stave (l970), "The drastic
changeover from the intrauterine to the extrauterine environment
is certainly the most hazardous event during the entire life-span
of mammals" (p. 38). McKilligin (1970) punctuates, "More
individuals die on the first day of life than on any subsequent
day, and about ten to fifteen percent have transitional problems
with varying degrees of morbidity" (p. 34). What McKilligin,
like the majority of his medical colleagues, fails to recognize
is the psychological experience of the child at birth. The
combination of physical and emotional stresses and assaults
at birth can be trying and even life-threatening. The life
threats a birth cause devastating emotional distress.
The ensuing psychological shock is commonly associated with
overwhelming life threats. Indeed, at times the trauma of birth
may result in a post traumatic stress reaction with life long
repercussions, if it is not empathized with, catharted and resolved
in infancy (Solter, 1984). Janov (l983) who has witnessed thousands
of regressions to birth experiences has observed : |
For many of us, birth is the closest we will come to death
for the rest of our lives until we are truly at death's
door. The possibilities for trauma at birth are multitudinous.
Many of these traumas are not obvious because what may be
exceptionally traumatic for the newborn passes as "normal"
from an outsider's point of view. (pp. 33-34)
|
I
have heard many people say they were told their birth was
normal. These supposedly normal births often have complications
like a long labour, terrifying asphyxiation, anaesthesia,
use of forceps, early cutting of the cord, being held upside
down and hit, invasions in the mouth and nose, burning drops
in the eyes, mutilation of the genitals and abandonment to
a nursery. Janov (l977) argues, "the reason the birth
trauma has such a tremendous [psychological] impact is that
it's a life-and-death situation" (p. 65). The ten to
fifteen per cent figure for infants with transitional problems
of physical morbidity which McKilligin refers to, does not
take into account the psychological and transitional problems
which are not emphasized by obvious physical injury or illness.
In this age of institutional birth, the majority of infants
have to cope not only with the biological ordeal of human
birth, but will also be subjected to numerous medical assaults
and invasions. Many of the traumas of birth which currently
arise in psychotherapy exist because of conditions found in
the hospital births of the past few generations of people.
|
 |
ONLY
TRAUMATIC BIRTHS ARE TRAUMATIC
There are some who suggest birth is nearly
always traumatic (Rank, l923; Fodor 1949), there are some
that suggest that only traumatic births are traumatic (Chamberlain,
1988; Peterson, 1984) and there are references to some people
reporting having experienced positive births that influenced
them in a positive way (Gabriel, 1992; Noble, 1993).
Much of what is know about the long lasting
psychological consequences of the pre- and perinatal psychological
realm comes from subjective and anecdotal accounts of clients
working through distress and emotional problems (Verny 1981;
Janov, 1983). As Furth (1988, p. 2) comments, "A positive
complex is not usually why a patient seeks a therapist."
The reports from the clinical setting are often biased toward
"looking at what needs to be fixed and therefore what
went wrong". Much of what we have clinically discovered
about the lasting influences of the pre- and perinatal experience
is apt to be skewed to the natally wounded. Verny (l981),
remarking on his study of birth experiences of individual
in therapy, agrees: |
Because of the unusual nature of the study group [psychotherapy
clients] I think these figures may be slightly distorted;
a more normal group of individuals would probably have a
somewhat lower incidence of damaging prenatal and birth
memories. But one of the advantages of studying a therapy
group is the magnification effect, which makes correlations
sharper and easier to observe. For example, 75 percent of
the subjects described themselves as introverts and 65 percent
said they presently felt angry, depressed or anxious. (pp.
70-71)
|
| The
"what went wrong" bias of the clinical impression
of pre and perinatal psychology is to be expected in context
of people seeking psychotherapy and personal growth work out
of difficulties related to emotional wounds. Speaking about
research sources in a chapter of his landmark book, Secret of
the Unborn Child, Verny (1981) cautions: |
If I seem to dwell excessively on the negative side of
a woman's thoughts and feelings in this chapter, it is only
because negative emotions have been studied far more exhaustively
than such positive ones as nurturing. I am afraid we physicians
sometimes manifest an overly energetic interest in the morbid
and pathological at the expense of the healthy and life-sustaining.
(p.72)
|
For
some, the final exit in the birth process can vary from pleasurable
to ecstatic, ranging from a sense of relief to one of accomplishment
and victory (Grof 1985). Feher (l980) suggests that in the
last stage of birth, "Some children just slip out. Others
find this part of birth an ordeal, especially if instruments
are used" (p. 191). The intervention of forceps at the
victorious time when the exuberant struggle of birth is nearly
over can be a patriarchal insult to the woman giving birth
and to the infant who has worked so hard. Having someone step
in and take over and interrupt the natural progression unfolding
can be a let-down and disappointment for woman and child,
and can create life-long feelings of resistance -- "Leave
me alone," and "Let me do it myself," for the
person robbed of the accomplishment of birth.
If the unity and flow of birth for mother
and child is not interfered with, birth can have elements
of pleasure and empowerment, as Khamsi (1987) notes: |
Many subjects described aspects of their birth feelings
as somewhat pleasurable in a sensual way. Some reported
periods of feeling energetic, "grounded," peaceful,
powerful, relieved, safe, secure, wonderful, and even ecstatic.
Two subjects were emphatic that they experienced no pleasure
during birth feelings, and a third experienced pleasure
only when it was over. (p. 54)
|
| Chamberlain
(1982) relates: |
Birth is a liberation struggle for some, particularly if
caught in the cord, or eager to get away from an undernourished
or psychotic mother. For others, however, it is not accurately
described as a struggle at all, and certainly not as a "cosmic
battle." I find that birth is separation from a comfortable
womb for most (though not all) depending mainly on the action
of the mother and her caregivers in childbirth. If she is
at ease and a cooperative mode with the infant and her own
body, the liberation at birth will usually have positive
connotations of great stimulation, achievement, and transformation
for both mother and newborn. On the other hand, if mother
is afraid, tense and resistant to what is happening, reports
in hypnosis reveal an anxious, painful struggle for the
infant. (p. 224)
|
Noble
(1993), speaking of her own birth, comments, "I was born
quickly and easily at home, and I never felt that I suffered
any trauma" (p. 43).
Individuals with primarily positive pre
and perinatal experience may be the exception to the rule.
In spite of her reference to her own "easy" home
birth, Noble (1903) notes, "The majority of people undertake
a primal journey because of dissatisfaction with their life
resulting from "not getting enough" in the womb.
They feel cut off from their emotions or shut down in relationships"
(p. 90).
The pleasure of birth is naturally related
to the degree of safety experienced in birth. In addition,
feelings of accomplishment and pleasure in birth are often
associated with the prenate feeling someone else in the birth
environment. This prenatal sense of the outside presence of
the mother and/or someone else in the birth environment can
be in response to emotional support and even empathy during
birth. |
 |
POSITIVE
PRE- & PERINATAL EXPERIENCES
There are accounts in the literature of
positive prenatal experiences influencing personality (Cheek,
1986; Chamberlain, 1988; Gabriel, 1992). Speaking of people
regressed prenatally through psychotherapeutic work with hypnosis,
Cheek (1986) relates: |
Most of the prenatal reports have related very stressful
experiences, but there was one instance of an unborn infant
feeling elated on hearing her mother really wanted a girl
and was knitting clothing for a girl. This case is included
here because the memory was substantiated by her mother
and accurately placed at l8-20 weeks gestation, and because
this fetal understanding seems to have had a beneficial
influence on the welfare and development of the child. (p.
98)
|
| To
fully understand what it is to be human I think we need to explore
more about the effects of positive pre and perinatal experiences.
Rowan (1988b) suggests, "We repress not only dark or painful
material in the lower unconscious, but also embarrassingly good
material in the higher unconscious" (p. 92). Verny (1991)
and others in the pre- and perinatal psychology field surmise,
"Birth and prenatal experiences form the foundations of
human personality. Everything we become or hope to become, our
relationships with ourselves, our parents, our friends -- all
are influenced by what happens to us in these two critical periods"
(p. 118). The conclusions of the significance of birth are often
drawn by psychotherapists who, as Verny (1981) commented earlier,
"seem to dwell excessively on the negative side...the morbid
and pathological at the expense of the healthy and life-sustaining"
(p.72). Psychotherapy often deals with distress and problematic
life issues, and it is in this context that psychotherapists
have been introduced to the influences of birth.
Birth and the prenatal realm have another
face for some. I spoke with a sculptor, who was also a grandmother.
She said that she had always had a love of the sounds of hammers
and construction. In the middle of all the sawing of lumber
and clatter of tools she felt a special calm and relaxed feeling.
A major renovation on her current house was nearing completion
and she was already feeling a sadness that she was going to
miss the sounds of the work. Over her life she had occasionally
wondered what might have influenced these intensely pleasurable
feelings.
When looking at and talking about my natalistic
art, similar feelings came to her, and she made the connection
that while in her mother's womb her parents were finishing
construction on a house. Both the building of their own home
and having a child come into their life were special to the
parents. While becoming a member of a family she lived in
a happy womb, surrounded with the constant pulse of the maternal
heart but also surrounded with the rhythm of hammers and saws.
It is possible these pleasurable conditions were still felt
decades later. Sounds and the creativity of building through
her sculpting were central features in her life and they seemed
to have come from the initial early imprinting.
May-Gaskin (1977) forwards, "The
knowledge that each and every childbirth is a spiritual experience
has been forgotten by too many people in the world today,
especially in countries with high levels of technology"
(p. 11). Schwartz (1980) suggests that while birthing her
baby the woman can have sensations which Maslow (1973) coined
as "peak experiences." Schwartz (1980) elaborates,
"childbearing can precipitate transcendent, ecstatic
emotional states, similar to those cause by other intense
experiences such as orgasm or the creation of art, contact
with nature, or a spiritual experience" (p. 78). Schwartz
(1980) suggests the pregnant mother, as well, may experience
"complex dimensions" of an "altered state during
the childbearing year" (p. 78). |
| Through
the multiple layers possible in artistic metaphor, Goertzen's
natalistic sculpture, Infant Joy (figure 5.p), expresses and
explores the interrelated experiences of infancy, birth and
the prenatal domain. Sculptor Jake Goertzen forwards that the
foundation imprint of a positive womb period was pivotal in
helping him to cope with a childhood of neglect and abuse. He
found reconnecting with the "life force" of the pre-
and perinatal realm was of valuable assistance in his psychotherapeutic
healing (see link...Jake Goertzen Sculptor: Awakening to the
Womb Through Sculpting the Infant and link...Jake Goertzen Sculptor:Tilling
the Garden Through Art). |

Figure 5P: "Each and every childbirth is a spiritual experience."
Infant Joy: Goertzen. |
 |
BENIGN
BIRTH INFLUENCES
Occasionally, birth experiences
can manifest as small quirks in behaviour or feelings which
are not necessarily dysfunctional, as Feher (1980) notes:
|
For example, one patient always woke up at two in the morning
to raid the refrigerator. It turned out that 2 a.m. was
her first feeding time after birth. Another had increased
concentration abilities about four in the afternoon. It
was no surprise to discover that this was the hour she had
woken after her first post-birth sleep." (pp. 73-74)
|
|
These birth patterns may give rise to unique quirks which
do not cause the person any distress, unless they develop
into a sleeping or eating disorder.
I worked with an administrator whose demanding
job at times required working long days. Therefore, a full
night's sleep was important to him. While working through
relationship issues around need, he began waking up hungry
at five in the morning with a longing feeling and pain around
his navel. After a snack, he was still unable to fall asleep
and was beginning to feel exhausted during the day. In his
case, waking up too early was becoming a problem.
When the birth and infancy element to
the issue came to light, he worked on this with abreaction,
art and talking: but he also felt a need to look after his
infant within. He bought baby food for his early morning snacks
and for a few weeks while having them, he imaged his inner
infant receiving the caring and nurturing he desired and missed
originally as a newborn. Through self-care and self-love,
he was able to fall back to sleep, as well as to repattern
the early need. |
 |
| LOSS
AT BIRTH
While in birth regression, people sometimes
experience an emotional pain which feels like the mother was
not present or that she vanished emotionally during the struggle
of birth. For people in Khamsi's (1987) research group: |
Needing help and having to struggle unassisted were common
themes. Several subjects spoke explicitly about their mother's
being out of contact or uncooperative with them, or of doing
nothing at all to help. There is an indication that aggression
may have become stronger when cooperation with the environment
(i.e., the mother) seemed lacking. Several subjects reported
feeling that they had a job to do, and aggression seems
to have mounted when this mission was blocked. (p. 54)
|
| Khamsi
(1987) describes further from the reports of individuals who
had numerous birth regressions while in therapy: |
Many subjects blamed their births for
a variety of feelings and characterological traits (e.g.,
feeling crowded, fearful, frustrated, helpless, isolated,
jealous, panicky, pressured, and vulnerable). Most common
were disturbed relationships with mothers, and subjects
generally believed this had originated during or even before
birth. Subjects often felt their mothers did not help, love,
reassure, support, or want them adequately. They reported
a lack or loss of cooperation and contact, and sometimes
became furious or contemptuous toward their mothers. (p.
55)
|
In
the tribulation of birth the child can experience a deep sense
of loss, rejection or abandonment from the person who had
been the central figure of trust, dependability and nurture
in life. These early feelings can leave life-long patterns
of lack of trust, isolation, loneliness and longing. Some
people have a global feeling that the world, all of life,
has betrayed them in this sudden and unfair upheaval. |

Figure 5Q: The Dead Mother and the Black Coffin: From
Naumburg (1966). |
| The
loss and near death of birth can become an emotional theme in
life. Conversely later life losses can be coped with and interpreted
through the feelings and messages of birth -- positive or negative.
Naumburg (1966) presents a client whose conflicts with loss
and "obsession with pregnancy" was depicted in many
of her drawings. In the drawing, The Dead Mother and the Black
Coffin (figure 5.q), there is an umbilical cord from the womb-like
oval to one of the figures. For the artist there is perhaps
a psychological connection between later life loss and the loss
or near death experiences at birth or in the womb. |
 |
|
FOETAL
AWARENESS OF EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT
It seems the infant at birth can
have feelings or perceptions of whether the mother, or even
other people in the environment are welcoming or rejecting.
There are people who report being cognizant of a variety of
maternal awarenesses and emotions during the prenatal and
birth periods. This is the case with particularly intense
and/or repeated feelings. Verny (1981) mentions a Caesarean
born woman who, "recalled her mother's dread as the surgeon
prepared the incision: 'I could feel her terror as the knife
began cutting across her stomach'" (p. 107). These early
perceptions can establish part of the characteristics of the
emotional relationship between the person and the environment
of later life.
While in early regression people have
reported knowing about thoughts, feelings, conditions -- not
only in the mother -- but in the environment around the mother.
Some individuals have reported an awareness of the experience
of feelings or attitudes of the father, like whether he wanted
a child of one gender or another. |
One can interpret these reports as indicating
that prenates have an ability, through some dynamic, to read
the emotions of the people in their environment. One must
wonder how this information is received. It may be difficult
to explain exactly how the awareness occurs, but it is an
experience reported by many at birth. Feher (1980) suggests
that, at birth the child may be affected by maternal emotions
when, "endorphins or similar substances known to affect
pain are transmitted from the mother to the foetus during
labour. If so, the degree of pain she suffers may affect him,
and have repercussions on his consciousness" (p. 75).
Verny suggests that, in addition to the transfer of emotions
by hormones from the maternal circulatory system, there is
a fetal/maternal clairvoyance which is some kind of intuitive
reading of the other. Verny (1981) considers, "an unborn
child can sense his mother's thoughts and feelings" (p.
43). |

Figure 5R: The prenate marinates in the emotional waters of
the maternal womb -- a womb surround drawing from a Natalistic
Art Workshop. |
It
is reasonable to consider that an intense emotion like maternal
terror could be absorbed as a generalized feeling of fear
by the foetus. This could easily be explained by the passing
of triiodothyronine or thyroxine, which accelerates the metabolism,
of the fear hormone ACTH, across the placenta (Ganough, 1974).
But Verny (1981) and others speak of the prenate having awareness
of much more discreet and specific material than generalized
emotions from maternal hormones. Verny (1981) claims: |
A highly complex subtle emotion such
as ambivalence provides an even better example. As we have
seen, ambivalence can have a harmful effect on an unborn.
Yet, there is almost certainly no physiological state connected
with it. The emotion is often so muted, the woman herself
isn't even aware of it. I think the only logical explanation
for these findings is what I have called "sympathetic
communication". Evidently the child's emotional radar
is so sharp that even the slightest tremors of maternal
emotion register with him. (p. 89)
|
| In
regression, people sometimes report having a keen and subtle
awareness of maternal feelings, attitudes and even specific
thoughts. The connection
with maternal consciousness by the foetus may be a combination
of feelings generated by hormones passing across the placenta,
combined with intuition or some kind of mental perception,
with a knowing which could be attributed to the extraordinarily
close physical proximity these two people share. If any two
people were wrapped in an embrace for months on end, after
a while they would likely begin to develop a fairly intuitive
sense of what the other was experiencing, perceiving, or thinking
about and considering what to do next. It is possible the
mother perceives the larger environment and the prenate perceives
her perception. |
I
find that when people make natalistic art, especially when
using the technique drawing within a drawn womb surround,
that the clients will often also incorporate psychological
material, emotions and issues predominantly outside the womb
surround. Inside the womb surround will be found the feelings
that those maternal emotions activated for the prenates and
the means by which they protected themselves or took care
of their mothers. A comparison of the images, lines and colours
inside and outside the womb surrounds often reflect toxic
maternal material which penetrated into the womb environment.
This content can be drawn completely unconsciously and unbeknownst
to the artist. |

Figure 5S: Two womb surround drawings: the left side explores
womb trauma, the right side nurtures and repatterns the negative
prenatal affect.
|
| When
maternal material repeatedly infiltrates the in utero environment
and the fetus it becomes merged with the prenate's identity
and sense of self. When this is a legacy of birth and womb experience
one of the therapeutic issues is to become aware of boundaries
between fetal and maternal emotion and distress. Natalistic
art is a valuable way to discover the discreet parts in this
merging. It helps to re-establish separateness and boundaries.
A vivid example of toxic parental emotions penetrating the
womb can be found in the art of Dali which expressions can
be found in the overwhelming feelings of his parents' unresolved
grief over the loss of an earlier child. Dali spoke directly
of the prenatal influence in his art. The prenatal elements
of Dali's art is discussed further in Goertzen
as a Natalistic Artist. |

Figure 5F: As a pioneer in natalism Dali explores nagative
prenatal grief through his art.

Figure 5U: Dali feels he psychologically returned to the realm
of the womb through his artistic activities. |
| Verny
(1981) considers that during birth, the prenate can be, "acutely
aware of his mother's feelings, and often his or her memory
of those maternal emotions may surface decades later, spontaneously
or in therapy" (p. 106). Verny (1981) reports on one woman
who in therapy: |
began describing how frightened her mother had been during
her birth, how she felt that fear had made her mother withdraw
into a protective ball. "I knew she wasn't going to
help me be born," the woman said, "and I was scared
because I'd have to do it all by myself." (p. 107)
|
| Imprints
from these kinds of birth experiences can leave life patterns
of not reaching out for help and always taking on too much responsibility. |
 |
GLOBAL
FEELINGS OF BIRTH
As mentioned earlier, the physical risks
of birth can be traumatic due to their life-threatening nature.
The attitudes and emotional atmosphere surrounding birth can
impact in what Khamsi (1987) describes as, "global, pervasive
impressions about existence" (p. 49). In this regard
the prenate's experiences affects that person's later basic
emotional and social sense of relationship to the greater
world. Khamsi reports, "These 'lessons' were allegedly
recognized during birth feelings and ostensibly learned at
birth. The lessons included feeling held back, held down,
helpless, unloved, or unwanted" (p. 49). The global perceptions
in part have to do with the metaphorical physical relationships
to the world and life's events; and a lifetime of self-image
and self-worth. One's basic sense of personal value and purpose
can be coloured by the emotional experience of birth. Khamsi
ventures that in the context of global impressions: |
Subjects claimed to learn that they
don't have enough "space" in life, that they always
have to "push like hell," or can't "get anywhere"
without being rescued. Self-concepts seemed tarnished as
well, with subjects reportedly learning at birth that they
were stupid, inadequate, or a failure. (p.49)
|
| One
bright and talented artist who survived three attempted abortions
by his mother, relived a sense of global despair related to
his perception that when the pregnancy became several weeks
past the official due date his parents, and in particular his
father, were wondering if he was going to be born deformed or
retarded. For him the prenatal concerns were strong and were
layered on the feelings of prior rejection as a result of the
attempted abortions. He worried he might be retarded. In part,
he spent his childhood feeling he was somehow retarded and at
the same time he was screaming out through his accomplishments,
"See me, I'm normal." He felt that the parental thought
around the time of his birth imprinted into the basic constitution
of his psyche. |
 |
THE
LEGACY OF BIRTH
Early traumas are commonly at least one
artifact of the various core issues in an adult's psyche and
will show up in the art work and personal issues brought to
or surfacing in therapy. The earliest life experiences can
be viewed as the foundation stones upon which the architecture
of the personality is constructed. According to Janov (1983): |
The encoding of traumas in and around birth has a special
significance for several reasons. First, the nervous system
of the baby is "naive": the defensive mechanisms
are not yet operating at full capacity to blunt and desensitize
the baby to what comes in. Second, traumas around birth
have an exceedingly high charge value because they are nearly
always a matter of life and death. The charge value of the
trauma is part of the imprint and retains a commensurate
force. In a traumatic birth, the baby's system is in great
danger and every ounce of effort is being expended in the
fight for survival. The highly charged imprint of that fight
is literally an electrical storm which remains in the system
as residual tension for a lifetime. Third, the birth imprint
is especially important because it is encoded deep and central
in the brain and nervous system, and is soon gated over
by the developing cortex and by later experience. (p. 16)
|
| For
some people, the experiences of trauma at birth seem to be of
pivotal and of paramount importance. When working through birth
issues, they report overwhelming birth events as the central
influencing factors in their lives. When working with art, these
factors may be found expressed as much in the processes of creating
the art as in the content of the art. For the individual locked
in the overwhelming struggle of birth, there may have been some
form of struggle to get to the session. There can be feelings
of having to struggle to get started with, or get through some
stuck point in creating (birthing) the work. Conversely, Khamsi
(1987) has observed that for some people: |
birth feelings were regarded as simply one among several
notable occurrences in therapy. Many had difficulty separating
the effects of birth feelings from other aspects of therapy.
Some described birth feelings as continuous with other experiences
or as components of a much larger process. (p. 52)
|
| The
overwhelming and unresolved feelings of birth may be buried
through repression or dissociation but they are not totally
extinguished. As was noted by Khamsi (1987) earlier, some of
the most commonly reported lingering feelings of birth are fears.
Feher (1980) has found that often the later life: |
Fear of tunnels, bridges or elevators can be traced back
to birth. Dreams of creeping, going through narrow openings,
sinking, drowning, being crushed, suffocated, pulled down
or out, falling, being released, flying and being buried,
violated, controlled or pressured are all birth associated.
(p. 194)
|
These
fears in adult life can be a shadowing legacy of the threatening
conditions of the vulnerable and helpless infant being cataclysmically
constricted during the passage of the birth canal.
Claustrophobia is not just the fear of
being confined by a space; it also has a component of a fear
of having one's way blocked, and a desperate need to get free.
There can be a desperation to get to a place with breathing
room, as in the case of the active third grade student of
whom Emerson spoke. Lake (1980) explains: |
The Latin root claustrum is a bar, or bolt, or lock. In
this sense claustrophobia is not simply fear of the reduced
space, but of the bolts and locks that bar the way out....
Claustrophobia is a fear of walls and things, not people.
It also has to do with travel in closed compartments, whether
in trains or buses, the greatest fear being expressed as
the mid-point approaches. The fear is that you are not in
control, and you can't get out, so the expense of a taxi
may become a necessity. The fear of tunnels, narrow underground
passages and clefts in the earth or the rocks come under
this theme. The fear is one of crushing, of the mountains
falling on your head and suffocating you. (p. 12)
|
The
feelings and metaphors for claustrophobia arise for many people
as the birth content of their personal issues begins to surface
in therapy. These experiences can become particularly acute
when the person is actually working with the memories.
I worked with a social worker whose paralysing
fear of heights, bridges and cliffs had many of these same
features of fear of suffocating, constriction and impending
doom found associated with claustrophobia. In therapy, he
connected the feelings with childhood threats and terror at
birth. Several years later, after his birth work, we shared
hot chocolate and cookies from a perch high above the top
of nearby building. We scaled some open construction scaffolding,
taking in the spectacular colours of a fall day in the city.
A decade earlier he would have never suggested climbing a
ladder, much less venturing on such a challenging adventure.
While in regression with natalistic art, feelings can come
back as somatic sensation accompanying the art processes.
It is important to voice the physical sensations experienced
while producing therapeutic art. Being more aware of them
may allow a clearer understanding of the original birth experience
and its effects on life issues. Very often these somatic birth
feelings need cathartic expression. This can be accomplished
by projecting the sensation or feeling into a work of art,
giving the body feelings sounds, movement, or words. While
employing natalistic art in therapy the client often uses
a combination of methods to release the emotional energy of
the birth memory. |
 |
ELABORATION
OF THE IMPRINT
Many pre and perinatal theorists
suggest that the events surrounding birth are more likely
to become life-long birth feelings or birth patterns when
they are reinforced by later childhood events or strong parental
attitudes (Feher, 1980; Lake, 1981; Verny, 1981; Janov, 1983;
Noble, 1993). Many varied experiences can occur during birth,
and in comparison, there is an even greater number of childhood
experiences which can reinforce or compound the original birth
trauma (Lake, 1979). Those later childhood events become interpreted
through the lenses which were created to view and capture
significant early events. Feher (1980), in writing of natal
therapy, acknowledges that the development of personality
is a fluid unfolding, "because we see all behaviour patterns
as continuous: initiated in the womb, imprinted at birth,
then remaining dormant until they become manifest at later
critical stages of development" (p. 77).
The trauma of birth increases with the
intensification of the infant's experience of isolation, helplessness,
physical pain and fear. Khamsi (1987) reports: |
Breathing often seemed pivotal in this regard. When breathing
seemed free and easy during birth feelings, subjects often
claimed to have felt ecstatic, to have sensed that the world
is a safe and nurturing place, and to have believed that
life is good. When breathing was problematic, however, subjects
claimed to feel that they were in danger, to sense that
they "weren't going to make it," and to believe
that life is a struggle with which they can get no help.
(p. 50)
|
The sense of not being helped and
that no one is there for the child during the struggles can
turn turmoil into cataclysm. For the vulnerable infant who
has to put aside and suppress these overwhelmingly painful
feelings, later life events may be haunted by behavioural
responses and feeling expressions of many of the experiences
of birth.
Significant wounds to the psyche in the
child can elicit the forces of a dormant early stress and
in the later childhood event turn the initial birth stress
into a birth trauma (Feher, 1980). The more a childhood stress
or trauma coalesces with the feelings or conditions of the
pre- or perinatal experience, the more likely it is that a
layering will occur with the original early trauma and its
feelings and issues.
For some the perinatal wounds are forever
present as part of life's ongoing anxiety; these people may
live in a constant state of birth feelings (Janov, (1983).
For others the material of a trauma at birth comes to life
in response to a particular childhood trauma or developmental
stress. Grof (1985) concludes: |
The actual nature and duration of childbirth
is not the only factor in the development of psychopathology.
It is obvious that among individuals whose birth was comparable,
some may be relatively normal, while others could show various
types and degrees of psychopathology. The question is how
to reconcile this variation with the obvious significance
of the perinatal level of the unconscious. The pool of difficult
emotions and physical sensations derived from the birth
trauma represents only a potential source of mental disorders.
Whether psychopathology develops, what specific form it
takes, and how serious it will be are critically co-determined
by the individual's postnatal history and, thus, by the
nature and dynamics of the COEX systems [stages of birth].
|
|
These are some of the most important
messages which pre and perinatal psychology has to share:
that what is most significant for the young infant and prenate
in the womb is the care, empathy and love communicated to
the child during and following the stresses of birth. It is
not necessarily the physical trauma which creates the emotional
shock which will have life-long effects on the person, but
rather how empathic and supportive parents are to the child
at the time of birth and later throughout childhood.
The long term follow-up studies of Emerson
(1987) show that eighty-eight percent of children after having
undergone his birth refacilitation therapy do not follow the
usual behaviour characteristics of their particular type of
birth, while twelve percent of treated infants still follow
through with, "pathological symptom patterns" congruent
with their particular birth schema. What seems to have happened
with the treated but still traumatized children was that the
parents were not supportive and empathic (that is the twelve
percent failure group), and therefore reinforced the birth
trauma in spite of the infants undergoing therapy (recent
work of Emerson, soon to be published, shows, after further
development of his approach, an even lower failure rate).
In the untreated control group, eighty-five percent of children
developed birth schemas in personality symptomatic of their
type of birth while fifteen percent of the children showed
no latent signs of birth trauma (Emerson, 1987). |
 |
|
AVERTING
AN IMPRINT FROM TRAUMA AT BIRTH
The fifteen percent of untreated children who did not
internalize a life time pattern symptomatic of their type
of birth were children whose parents were sensitive and supportive
(Emerson, 1987) says, "They seemed to be 'natural parents,'
very much at ease with their children...they had the capacity
to guess the likely outcomes of their child's birth"
(p. 63). In other words, these fifteen percent of parents
did not reinforce the various birth feelings that life is
violent, that you fight to get what you want, that everything
is pressure, and those whom you need most are going to suffocate
and strangle you with their authority. The parents may even
intuit the help the child needs to overcome the shadow of
birth. For instance Emerson (1987) points to one father of
a breech birth child who: |
Guessed that his son might be directionally
confused (one of the outcomes of breach birthing). The parents
were able to consider negative outcomes in a relaxed (rather
than serious) manner, and often with a sense of humour.
The relationship with their child seemed contactful, caring,
and free of manipulation or control. (p. 63)
|
|
Emerson (1987) has observed that it is
more often later life conditions which entrench the initial
negative life impressions perceived during birth. In his research
and clinical work Emerson has observed, "children who
developed pathologic patterns were exposed to exacerbating
conditions. For example, one infant experienced severe containment
during birth, and was also locked up in a closet by his brother
and tied to a tree by friends" (p. 63). For this child,
the restriction in the birth canal became part of the emotional
force of specific and isolated later events. For another child,
the reinforcement of being restricted could be the ongoing
daily restriction of a long-term chronic illness, or a constantly
controlling parent (Lake, 1981). It is when the conditions
of birth are reinforced or recreated by childhood factors
that a layering or compounding of the birth trauma and its
influences occurs (Janov, 1983). |
 |
|
ENVIRONMENTAL
FAMILIARITY
It is probable that when life's later
conditions resonate enough with a perinatal distress, then
the child or adult returns to the previous stress to seek
assistance from the lessons of the earlier painful experience.
Unfortunately, the repeated traumas can prove to the growing
child that negative or dysfunctional learning from a painful
time has some validity, and the person's wounded views may
become more deeply entrenched. Lake (1978a) comments, "The
experience of a bad birth becomes particularly crippling if
it is locked-in and reinforced by a constrictive upbringing"
(p. 11). As an example, the child of a long labour who later
is pushed by a parent for whom the child can never be quite
good enough. The child's birth schema of, "Getting started
is really hard," becomes more deeply ingrained into "Life
is really hard on me, and I can never be good enough."
Their art work is hard to produce. They feel stuck with starting
a picture which will not be good enough. In childhood, the
unsatisfiable parent became the life long birth canal which
the constricted child was always trying to get through, all
the while fearing they never would.
Conversely if a child experienced a long
labour with feelings of, "It is really hard to get through
things. I do not have the energy to finish;" and then
a supportive parent is intuitively aware the child is challenged
by a sense of difficulty in life activities. The parent may
naturally help the child overcome the sense of hardship. Lake
(1978a), who expresses the view that a bad birth can become
crippling when reinforced, also considers, "where an
upbringing can provide warmth and security, all but the severest
shocks to the energy-system at birth can be largely compensated
for" (p. 11). In being supportive and nurturing, the
parent will point out and praise the child's accomplishments
with empowering praises like, "Oh, look what you did.
Wow,!" or, "Look how far you've come along,"
or "Gee! You sure made that look easy." If the child
says, "I can't do this, it takes forever," the encouraging
and supportive parent might reply, "It looks hard, but
I'm sure you can do it. Would you like some help the first
time?" The parent gives the child some other form of
healthy validation and encouragement. This intuitive support
and praise will serve to repattern self-inhibiting or self-defeating
birth trauma issues, the origins of which the parent may not
even thoroughly know. When early life demonstrates a reality
different than the initial birth trauma to the child, then
it is possible that the messages of, "Life is hard, I
can't get through," will not become a life long feeling
pattern and belief.
Emerson (1987) found, in researching the
behaviour patterns of children who previously experienced
trauma during their births, that some children did not show
personality traits expected to be associated with their particular
birth experience. Emerson (1987) comments about these symptom-free
children, "We also noticed an absence of reinforcing
trauma...i.e., their childhoods were free of reinforcing conditions"
(p. 63). If the child does not find their birth fears shadowing
them in life, then the child can be open to new lessons. The
child with a constricting umbilical cord around the neck at
birth can learn from a care free childhood and supportive
parents that, contrary to the birth experience, change does
not always "tie you up" and there are lots of opportunities
for fresh air and open spaces. |
 |
|
INJURY
OR ILLNESS AS BIRTH TRAUMA REINFORCEMENT
Birth traumas are not reinforced solely
by dysfunctional parenting. There simply are some life hurts
and tragedies that come with the territory of living. Sometimes
accidents during birth can cause the initial trauma: and then
unfortunately, an accident(s) or operation(s) in later childhood
will cause the reinforcement of the original negative response
pattern. For example, if a child had a shoulder caught or
even broken during birth, and then broke an arm or shoulder
early in childhood, those incidents can become compounded
into a life message like, "When you try out something
new you get hurt." These messages are initiated as a
form of self protection, but can develop into hypersensitivity
or an alertness which can verge on hyper-vigilance. Problematic
life patterns and messages were initially specific remedies
most often carefully chosen, for dealing with some trauma
or ongoing stress. Lake (1979) affirms: |
They become imprinted, and there is
a tendency later in life to have them as a kind of scanning
mechanism, seeking out possibly similar experiences so as
to be forewarned and forearmed of their approach and be
prepared to deal with them. Often in the same way: that's
the problem. The remedy is out of date. (p. 14)
|
|
The child who breaks a shoulder
when moving into a new environment outside of the womb, and
then again breaks an arm when trying out a new kind of swing,
tries to prevent broken bones by avoiding new adventures.
Unfortunately exciting activities and events may be avoided
or passed over with the unintended repercussions of boredom
and lack of challenge for a bright and inquisitive child.
Another example of psycho/social reinforcement
of the birth trauma with an added physiological factor would
be the situation of a child from a family with a history of
asthma; who, due to asphyxiation in a long drugged birth,
experiences difficulty in breathing. The original birth trauma
could be interpreted as, "During life's stresses it is
hard to breathe;" or "It is hard to get breathing
room;" "The harder you try something, the harder
it is to breathe" (Holden, l983). In part, the breathing
trauma of birth would register psychophysiologically in the
lungs, which is also a part of the body which is primarily
genetically vulnerable for this particular child. Environmental
allergies, bronchitis or pneumonia occurring in infancy can
solidify the onset of childhood asthma. In this case, the
child's asthma would have roots first in a biological weakness,
second in the asphyxiation trauma at birth and third in illness
or environmental allergies (Mellet, 1978). If subsequently
in childhood, breathing is difficult, particularly during
stressful activities or at certain times of the year, and
if, as well, a parent is over protective and smothering,the
child can feel there is no room to breathe. The physical and
emotional conditions of childhood help to create a compounded
layering of the original birth trauma perceptions and feelings
around breathing difficulties as a metaphor symbolizing life
(Noble, 1993). |
 |
|
CHILDHOOD
TRAUMA AS REINFORCEMENT
In a case similar to the one of the boy
who was tied to a tree by friends, Emerson (1984) discusses
a third grade student who was referred to him because of hyperactivity
and being behind academically several grades. It was observed,
"She preferred to sit near the door or windows of the
classroom and if she were to sit elsewhere her anxiety and
activity would increase" (p. 8). Over a number of birth
refacilitation sessions with Emerson, the child: |
experienced intense anxiety about
the contractions, and about containment in the womb. Several
associated memories occurred, she'd been locked in a closet
by her brother and another time she'd been locked in a small
sitting room by her mother. Both scenes were very traumatic
and very frightening to her. (p. 8)
|
|
Again the confinement of birth was compounded
by later childhood confinements with the result that the child
needed to be sure that, close by, there was a way to get out.
In daily life, when the way out was not near by, the girl
was very active, perhaps partly as a tension release and partly
as an expression of needing to be on the move -- "To
get out of here, NOW." Emerson reports that after working
with the traumatic birth and childhood material over a number
of sessions: |
The hyperactivity disappeared
almost completely, and was understood more in terms of claustrophobia,
a specific anxiety reaction to birth and associated reinforcing
conditions following birth.
Follow-up study a year later showed
that she was making better than age grade progress and that
progression towards more concentration and relaxation was
increasing. (p. 8). |
|
If she had been untreated it is possible
that over the years her childhood hyperactivity would have
resulted in further restrictions and control from her teachers
and parents with the result of further feelings of overwhelming
containment and a need for greater rebellion. |
 |
PHYSICAL
TRAUMA AT BIRTH
One of the keys to resolving the legacy
of early trauma is for clinicians not only to accept infant
consciousness, but to have some of the skills to recognize
the reverberations of birth issues. Pre- and perinatal traumas
often involve some degree of physical threat. As such it is
generally those psychotherapies which give credence to painful
physical experiences and their later somatic expression in
which clients will discover issues related to birth trauma.
Freudian and psychodynamic models have generally focused on
psychological interaction, the history of personal relationships,
family dynamics, and object relations. Generally these approaches
ignore the various physical traumas of life, unless in some
way the physical peril was a direct expression of relationships
and then it is often the psychology of the relationship and
not the psychology of the physical injury which is therapeutically
explored. Grof (1985) assures that, "In traditional psychology,
psychiatry, and psychotherapy, there is an exclusive focus
on psychological traumas. Physical traumas are not thought
to have a direct influence on the psychological development
of the individual or to participate in the genesis of psychopathology"
(p.97). There usually is not much of a consideration of how
illness, an operation, a broken leg or other physically threatening
medical or accidental experiences can become interwoven in
the fabric of the psyche. Grof (1985) explains that when a
child has to cope with, "a serious life-threatening disease,"
the psychology of the physical threat would not be of primary
concern; rather, "conventional psychology would focus
on the fact that the child, having been separated from the
mother at the time of hospitalization, experienced emotional
deprivation" (p. 98).
On the other hand experiential therapies
focusing on feelings often recognize and acknowledge body
urges and somatic sensations as part of the expression of
the inner psyche. These body expressions allow another layer
of the psyche to be explored therapeutically. Grof (1975;
1985) was one of the first to recognize the fundamental significance
of extreme physical discomfort, trauma, illness or operations
in his theoretical model of psychodynamics. Grof (1985) observes
that in the practice of: |
|
powerful experiential approaches, reliving
life-threatening diseases, injuries, operations, or situations
of near-drowning are extremely common and their significance
clearly far exceeds that of the usual psychotraumas. The residual
emotions and physical sensations from situations that threatened
survival or the integrity of the organism appear to have a
significant role in the development of various forms of psychopathology,
as yet unrecognized by academic science. (pp. 97-98) |
|
As has been noted previously, the experience
of birth can be filled with various forms of physical trauma.
Through acknowledging physical trauma and the impact of physical
experiences on personality Grof, (1975) ended up hearing from
his clients about operations or illnesses that might have
had an effect on personality. He also ended up reviving client
accounts of birth material which often involved physical risk
as a major component of the psychological trauma. |
 |
|
SOMATIC
EXPRESSION OF BIRTH MEMORY
When the beginnings of life have
been perilous, the area where the trauma was impacted during
birth is generally the same area where other later stresses
are stored and processed by the body. When the somatic expression
of anxiety and life patterns is explored, a relationship between
physical events and sensations of the perinatal environment
may be found to coalesce with a person's interpretation of
later environments and conditions. In processing later life
stresses, the person will have employed the areas of the body
and psyche which previously dealt with stress, and will be
therefore familiar with coping with stresses. Feher (1980)
notes, "The point of most traumatic climax in birth will
predispose the person to a pattern, and mark the choice of
symptom formation in any response" (p. 191).
Through somatic echoes of the stresses
of birth, later life stresses can be interpreted as various
forms of pressure, different means of having to get through
something, a variety of challenges to one's freedom or various
expressions of not being able to breathe. Being cheeky, heady,
elbowy, shouldering, a pain in the neck, a headache, breathless,
spineless, butt first, can all be somatic expressions of birth
conditions. They are birth elements to listen for in clients'
language, sentences and in art process and imagery. In clients'
drawings of an adult, child, baby or fetus, the points of
birth impact may unconsciously come out in the figure of the
drawing. When the client lies on a large piece of paper to
do a drawing, the point of perinatal impact on the body may
show up on the paper corresponding to the location of that
body part which was laying on the paper.
When the physical impact of trauma at
birth was to the shoulder, the person may develop a response
pattern of carrying the weight of the world on his or her
shoulders, or will be concerned with "just putting a
shoulder into it and pushing right through" -- perhaps
a good lineman. The area of the body which was impacted by
trauma in birth or during some prenatal injury is a site which
first learns to deal with stress. That region or exact spot
may "take the fall" in later stresses or accidents
because it "knows" what to do. Most people will
have a particular shoulder, leg, side of the body or area
of the head where a number of injuries have occurred.
Emerson suggests that this pattern of
absorbing stress in particular areas is an extension of the
original birth body schemas and is part of a movement pattern
associated with the patterns of a person's birth movements
and birth trauma. When the person slips and bumps into something,
or an object moves toward the person, the unconscious learned
instincts of the body spontaneously respond with the "right
place" to absorb and manage the impending trauma. In
art works, these sites of natal and repeated trauma may show
up as patterns or colours in particular areas of the drawings.
While doing art in therapy, those areas of birth impact may
become sore, tense or in some other way distressed. |
 |
|
CRANIAL
BIRTH TRAUMA
Verny (l981) claims, "Most
infants present frontally, which means the head and neck are
the two body areas that receive the greatest battering during
birth" (p. 118). The fascia or muscle tissue surrounding
the cranium may reveal some of the history of each individual's
birth. Areas of tension, soreness or pressure may be sites
of body memory about the stresses of birth. A light massage
or light pressure may assist the birth trauma memory to surface
therapeutically and reveal some of the feelings and issues
surrounding the trauma of birth.
It should not be surprising that
two common reactions to stress and life's obstacles are a
headache or feeling like things are "a pain in the neck".
Indeed, creating natalistic art can be associated with pressure
headaches or neck and back pain. As early as 1945 Greenacre
saw a relationship between the head sensation and headaches
which appear under stress and the experiences in the birth
canal. Greenacre (1945) forwards: |
In my experience the type of head
sensation may often be correlated quite definitely with
the form of birth experience of the individual and appears
under any conditions of very severe anxiety, but especially
in later life situations in which the subject of birth is
being stirred in the unconscious of the patient. (p. 48)
|
|
Noble (1993) agrees: |
Headaches commonly are birth related
and consist of many types. They can arise from natural birth
or instruments. Neck tension may be traced to improper head
rotation during birth. Migraines differ from pressure headaches
because they often result from oxygen loss at birth, coupled
with an associated build up of excess carbon dioxide. Carbon
dioxide is a powerful dilator of blood vessels, and that
sudden dilation is the chief ingredient of a migraine. Adult
stress evokes that original loss of oxygen with all its
painful repercussions. (p. 125)
|
|
Grof (1985) broadens this perspective,
and considers symptoms which point to birth traumas: |
The typical physical concomitants
of various emotional disorders make much sense if considered
in this light. They involve belt headaches or migraine headaches;
palpitations and other cardiac complaints; a subjective
sense of a lack of oxygen and breathing difficulties under
emotional stress; muscular pains, tensions, tremors, cramps,
and seizure-like activities; nausea and vomiting; painful
uterine contractions; activation of the gastrointestinal
tract, resulting in spastic constipation or diarrhoea; profuse
sweating; hot flashes alternating with chills; and changes
of skin circulation and various dermatological manifestations.
(p. 250)
|
|
The overwhelming terror experienced while
being trapped in or against the birth canal can be very real
for the infant. Roedding (1991) describes the feeling in this
way: |
The experience in the birth canal
can be a devastating and hopeless one, to say the least.
Crushing from the constriction of the vagina, suffocation
from prolonged pressure on the cord, forceps clawing at
a delicate and vulnerable head, drugs rendering the fetus
limp and even more helpless. (p. 155)
|
|
The head and lungs are the most severely
affected during the birth process. In the process of being
pushed against and then moving through the cervix, the body
is compressed and crushed to the degree of causing the skull
bones to reshape in a process called moulding. May-Gaskin
(1977) explains: |

Illustration by ADAM from AllRefer.com Health |
Moulding is the change in the shape
of the baby's skull that takes place when the moveable bones
of the skull that are loosely joined by membranes slide
over each other, reducing the circumference of the skull.
When these bones overlap, the frontal and occipital bones
pass under the partiental bones, and one of the parietal
bones may lip over the other. (p. 308)
|
|
During moulding the volume within
the skull does not change (May-Gaskin, 1977), but as the plates
of the skull can actually overlap each other and the volume
displacement inside the cranial cavity can be as much as 25%.
The adult head could not withstand the stresses and assaults
which occur to the infant head during birth. In a comparable
assault to an adult's head the cranium would be broken in
several locations with fatal consequences. Fortunately the
neonate's head is quite malleable and as yet not solidified,
plates of the cranium temporarily remould themselves in order
for the head to navigate the various obstacles in the passage
of the birth canal. Indeed more brain cells are lost during
birth than at any other time in life.
Often the cranium does not fully return
to its original shape after birth. The shape of most people's
heads show clearly some of the experiences of birth. While
slipping through the birth canal, the cranium becomes slightly
elongated in a direction in relation to the presenting features.
Oxorn (1980) describes as the soft bone infant skull moves
through the birth canal: |

Illustration by ADAM from U.S. National Library of Medicine

Cosmetic molding reminiscent of the
impact of birth
"Artificial cranial deformation by the prehistoric Peruvian
people."
|
Compression in one direction
is accompanied by expansion in another, and hence the volume
of the skull is not reduced....
Alteration of the shape of the head
is produced by compression of the presenting diameter, with
resultant bulging of the diameter that is at right angles.
For example, in the occipitoanterior [upper back of the
skull] position the suboccipitobregmatic [a diagonal circle
above and behind the ears from top front to lower back]
is the presenting diameter. The head therefore is elongated
in the verticomental diameter, with bulging behind and above.
(p. 44)
|
| The
shape of the extended, methodically reformed head of some ancient
Egyptians, Myans and others and similar head garments would
be an intensified illustration of the type of reforming of the
cranium that occurs during the birth process described above.
When the infant first comes out of the birth canal, the distorted
form of the head is most dramatic. It quickly begins to reshape
itself. If a bony plate has been displaced, the midwife may
press or massage it back into place. In some jurisdictions,
use of sacral cranial massage for assisting the return of the
cranial form is standard practice. |

The elongated headdress of Mentuhotep II, 2010-1998 BC; Illustration
from the VaticanMuseumsOnline |
|
When not remoulded, the cranium does not
fully return to its original shape after birth, rather an
imprint of birth is sculpted into the shape of the head. A
smooth straight forehead and a smooth straight face will likely
belong to a person who went through a no-labour, elective
caesarian section. The cranium of the person born by elective
caesarean generally does not have to engage the birth canal
or experience the deforming toil of the birth canal. In a
last minute caesarean section due to fetal distress in a long
labour, some cranial moulding may have begun, but as a whole,
the head and facial features are not significantly reformed
by the process of moving through the birth canal. The c-section
babies are the cute little darlings in the nursery. Their
faces are not all scrunched up from the arduous passage through
the birth canal. Lake (l966) has observed that, while in birth
regression, some people: |

Figure 5V: The cranial moulding of vaginal birth is depicted
in this natalistic drawing. |
are acutely aware that their experience
of the crushing of the head in the birth passages was so
severe as to reach the margin of tolerance and even to exceed
it. They have wished, like Job, that the gates of the womb
would close against them and that they might return deep
into the womb. Several patients have spoken of this moment
of indecision, as if it depended on the baby either to will
to go on, through the pain to the point of birth, or whether
to dissociate entirely from that forward movement in a death-wish,
or a regressive wish to return to the safe place (p. 625).
|
|
Fortunately, the fear and terror of birth
can be resolved and left behind as a memory of what was, and
no longer of what is. To be able finally to leave those overwhelming
emotions in the past it seems important to recognize and appreciate
their existence. |
 |
|
BIRTH
TRAUMA TO THE LUNGS
If the stress was to the lungs,
the person copes with stress through their lungs and issues
around breath. For instance, when the toddler is presented
with a stressful experience, the body remembers the initial
stress of birth, which became the prototype for stress. When
the young child's body is triggered into the shadow of the
not too distant birth feelings and memories, the body and
psyche employ the learning from the earlier stress to cope
with the current stresses. Lake (1979) suggests, " This
occurs because the dissociated primal experience is still
taking place on reverberating circuits and in cell memory.
This is exacerbated by current crises, ordering mobilisation
on all the old battle fronts" (p. 14). The child interprets
the ongoing life problem as emotional pressure, a parental
barrier or a hardship which has to be struggled through. |

Figure 5W: "Oxygen deprivation is a continual threat
in traumatic birth." image by Giger.
|
Birth
anxiety, as well as being stored in the skeletal musculature,
may be stored and resonate in the organs as well. An example
of a body carrying the anxiety of birth is the lungs in the
condition of asthma. Adults or children may come to birth
refacilitation therapy for dealing with both behavioral and
physical issues around asthma. Asthma is about breath and
not letting it go. The asthmatic's problem is in not letting
all his/her air out so new fresh air can replace it. The asthmatic
may be holding on and not letting go in other physical or
emotional ways as well. Janov (1983) claims that oxygen deprivation
is a continual threat in a traumatic birth as a result of,
"temporarily drowning in amniotic fluid.... having the
oxygen supply cut off by a twisted umbilical cord.... being
too drugged to take that first breath outside the canal"
(p. 83)
In these people, the initial trauma occurred to a therefore
is associated with, the lungs. Somatically, this is like when
impacts to the cranium and musculature are stored in the traumatized
site and become habituated schemas. |
|
Stress to the lungs resides in the tissue and musculature
surrounding the lungs. The lungs can therefore be a site that
resonates specific perinatal anxiety. Janov (1983) refers
to a study at the Pediatric Allergy Clinic of New York Hospital
where, "asthmatic children were found to have twice as
many neonatal complications as non-asthmatic children. The
researchers concluded: 'Clearly this study shows that a stressful
birth significantly increases the chances of a child's developing
asthma'" (p. 83). English (1985) drew a natalistic drawing
as a way of further exploring natal feelings of suffocation
and aesthesia which surfaced in a dream. According to English
(1985): |

Figure 5X: Drowning in numbing anesthesia and a lack of oxygen;
from English (1985). |
I awoke with an intense dream
image: A baby bottle tilted, nipple down, filled with water
or a pale juice. In it, there is a baby drowning
This dream seems to be about the aesthesia.
I may have experienced a lack of oxygen that felt like drowning.
the baby bottle is perhaps the uterus, and the fluid the
amniotic fluid [English's italics]. (p. 52)
|
 |
|
SOMATIC
METAPHORS
When the older child starts acquiring
developed language with metaphor, phrases like: "under
pressure", "up against the wall", and "can't
get through" feel right and congruent with the internal
experience of stress. Greenacre (1945) observes, "Birth
seems to organize the anxiety pattern, setting in motion the
genetically determined elements fused with those individually
determined ones resulting from the special or unique birth
experiences of the given infant" (p. 44). Essentially,
language and all its elaborations become layered on the long
term body responses which were manifested in birth and which
have been interpreting stressful situations since. Feher (1980)
concurs: |
If he chooses a response learned during
birth, the response is thereby reinforced and so has a greater
possibility of being chosen again. The next time he may
again choose and modify it, and again, so that by the time
he enters adulthood all his responses may be duplicated
or modified birth responses. (p. 19)
|
|
Over the decades, the threads of birth
can become quite woven into the fabric of life, so that physical
sensations, emotions, movement patterns, metaphors, language
elaborations, and life scripts can all be partially wrapped
in the unconscious cloth of birth. Janov (l983) presents one
client's brief account which demonstrates the complex twists
a highly traumatic birth experience can take: |
I could never tolerate anything over
me - anything overpowering me. My body seems to remember
something I can't really explain. It just feels like basic
survival. I know that I was born not breathing and almost
dead. My mother said I wasn't breathing at all and that
I was blue. Even the spanking by the doctor didn't help;
they had to give me an injection. It must have made me nauseous,
because nausea seems to be my first reaction to almost anything.
In any catastrophe I get a funny taste which seems to be
the dope they gave me at birth. I sort of smell it rather
than taste it. As soon as I get that smell I get all fuzzy-headed
and confused. (p. 20)
|
|
This man's struggle for survival
was manifest in his body telling him to avoid anything which
might overpower him. When he was in a crisis, it returned
to quite vivid sensations of the drugs used during the birth.
Greenacre (1945) considers there are a great variety of individual
variations: one person feels his anxiety with creepy sensations
in the skin, another in weakness in the legs, a third with
headache, a fourth with diarrhoea. One could go on to many
more examples. From a careful scrutiny of reconstructed material
from analytic patients, it seems that such patterning of the
anxiety reaction always represents the genetic constitutional
elements fused with birth experiences and further mediated
through and increased by the traumata of the early years,
with which we are so used to dealing in our analytic work.
(p. 44) |
|
When directly explored, the many metaphors
for the physical events and conditions of birth are often
fairly straight forward to identify and understand. When life
responses are viewed from the perspective of possible birth
content, many things quickly fall into place. Buchheimer (1987)
has observed "patients may be talking about their birth
when they use idiomatic expressions or metaphors" which
express the physical process and sensations of birth (p. 75).
To look at the metaphorical expressions of birth it is important
to review the physiological conditions of birth.
Asphyxiation and other physical hardships
and threats which take place in the process of birth seem
to leave physical impressions that later come out in the person's
world view, personality, life patterns or reactions to stress.
Janov (1983) also observes: |
Later situations of stress will tend
to elicit the prototypic sensations. Someone who fights
with his wife may find himself choking or becoming dizzy.
A grown child watching his parents fight may suffer from
feelings of suffocation which have no organic basis. Or,
the sensations can also persist in chronic form such as
a kind of endemic fatigue where fatigue is the result of
an excruciatingly long birth which became a stamped-in condition.
Under later stress the person's first response will be overwhelming
fatigue. (p. 71)
|
 |
|
BIRTH
SCHEMAS
Emerson calls the physical echoes
of birth "birth schemas". Emerson (1984a) has delineated
the various schemas which evolve out of birth movements. He
found that schemas are characterological, that they persist
into adulthood, and that they express as well as perpetuate
unintegrated primal trauma. Emerson (1987) asserts, "For
these reasons, it is important to diagnose dysfunctional birth
schemas.... and to initiate the discovery and repatterning
of more functional movements" (p. 66). |
Emerson (1989) suggests: |
Most early traumas are associated
with movement and with schematic development. For example,
the attempt to save oneself from an abortion attempt is
primarily one of movement (i.e., moving away from the threatening
force, whether biochemical or physical). Birth is a movement
experience, and an attempt on the part of the fetus to move
from the uterus to the world. Bonding and attachment involve
attempts on the parts of newly born children to move toward
(or away from) the birthing parents (with eyes, ears, and/or
anatomical parts). Movement forms an integral part of fetal
and infant learning, and associated schemas accrue into
adulthood. It is common to find prenatal and birth schemas
in the physical (although unconscious) repertoire of adults,
and to find that significant life patterns do not resolve
themselves until the prenatal birth schemas are repatterned.
(p. 200)
|
|
Emerson (l987) used video tapes
to observe and explore movement patterns in various settings,
and in particular people who were under stress or discussing
significant life issues. He noted, "These tapes show
that birthing movements become stylized, and are spontaneously
repeated in various postnatal circumstances. Repetition of
these movements allows a 'Diagnosis' of the movements and
pressures which occurred during birth" (p. 62)
The qualities of movement associated with
producing art can allow both assessment and repatterning of
the physical schematic level of birth trauma. To facilitate
clients' schematic repatterning, the clinician needs to become
familiar with these physical birth schemas and their meaning.
In the therapy setting, repatterning can be facilitated through
studying the clients' movement patterns while they are producing
art or while they are talking about their issues on video
tapes.
It is fascinating to review these video
tapes in either fast or slow motion. The person seems to have
a series of quirks in body movement while they are talking.
Usually, a movement pattern or set of movement patterns emerges
as a long segment is viewed. These movement patterns repeat
themselves and involve specific head movements and/or perhaps
a hand repeatedly touching a specific head or shoulder location.
For example during speech, the head may push down. As the
theme of conversation develops the person touches a particular
spot on the side of the face. A few words later the head will
push out in that direction. As the "point" of the
argument emerges, the person twists the head as though navigating
it up and out. When the point is finished the person will
physically gesture his/her relief at getting through this
ordeal. While engaged in conversation, the person has followed
a head motion and movement sequence pattern similar to that
of his/her passage through the birth canal. It is as though
the person's birth schemas are impacting on life patterns
and are being continually relived in the physical manifestation
of language. Observation of physical movements and their patterns
during conversation can give an encapsulated view of larger
birth patterns manifested in the individual's response to
the stresses of adult life. |
 |
|
BIRTH
SCHEMAS IN ART
It is quite remarkable that, in
a body schema which has developed from a traumatic forceps
birth, the person will reach a point of confusion in conversation
or in drawing. At this point, their head may shake back and
forth as the person somatically tries to wrestle free of the
forceps and the current argument or conflict with the art
which his or her forceps-oppositional personality has got
him/her into. When a shoulder has been stuck particularly
painfully or for a long time during birth, the person may
lean into the conversation or push with that shoulder while
drawing. Some people will grab their head just as they are
trying to get through a particularly difficult part of their
conversation or art; others touch their navel when feeling
something is missing in what they are saying or drawing. They
are reaching for or pointing out that there are issues around
a lost umbilical friend.
In daily life and relationship patterns,
the body schemas are often accompanied by associated language,
belief system and behavioral metaphors. The "forceps
person" may be heady and oppositional, trying to use
his or her head to break free from, and work out, the stresses
which often "grip" his/her head while working through
a task. Their art work may involve some form of oppositional
struggle which is solved through using the head. Somebody
with breathing or asphyxiation problems at birth may place
a palm on his/her chest or mouth, (subconsciously indicating
where the stress is occurring speech and drawing. They may
use metaphors of being suffocated in relationships or needing
room to breathe. |
 |
|
REPATTERNING
PHYSICAL SCHEMAS
In working with infants and young
children around an assortment of conditions, Emerson (1987)
discusses problematic personality traits or physical disorders
which are beginning to develop, and diagnoses, through observation
and physical manipulation, birth movement schemas which have
begun to habituate in the tissue and in movement patterns.
One infant Emerson (1987) describes had
a right-occiput (ROA) presentation: |
her birth position was on her right
side, facing the left arm of her mother. As she emerged
from the womb, her head rotated counterclockwise a quarter
turn, and then corrected back to its original position as
the right occiput and anterior portion of her head presented
itself upon birth. As we placed her in this position and
physically simulated the womb and the pelvic orifice with
our bodies and hands, she initiated these exact movements,
with associated emotional catharses. (p. 62)
|
|
To support birth refacilitation, Emerson
(1987) frequently uses the techniques of womb-simulation,
psychomotor re-stimulation and physical simulation which,
"involves a gentle re-creation of the physical aspects
of birth" (p. 62). With the gentlest of "birth massage"
and "birth refacilitation" the birth anxiety is
brought to the surface. At first, seeing his work, it is often
surprising to observe how the infant will clearly take charge
of recreating his/her birth drama. This provides a means of
telling the story, discharging the anxiety, and accepting
the empathy and acknowledgement offered to him/her.
These children seem to know that
they need to release the pent up anxiety in their bodies and
gravitate towards empathic recognition and acknowledgement.
To observe this work with infants is a telling experience.
It demonstrates the naturalness and validity of the therapeutic
growth process. These youngest of people have at their core
an innate motivation to work towards psychological health,
resolution and integration. |
 |
|
LABOUR
LIE
Emerson identifies one form of body schema
as being related to what he calls the labour lie. The labour
lie is the side and position the baby is in before labour
starts and before the baby's head engages for the descent
through the birth canal. The baby often lies on one side or
the other for a couple of weeks before the labour starts.
The side of their labour lie is often also the side a person
will tend to sleep on. Often the side the client naturally
and intuitively chooses to lie on to do a birth regression
drawing will be the side of the labour lie. |
| The
side of the labour lie and areas of the infant's body which
were particularly impacted by trauma during birth will be the
side or part of the body which will have greatest availability
towards birth recall. In addition, the side of the labour lie
and those areas of the body impacted by birth trauma will be
the areas with a predisposition to absorb and manage later life
injuries, traumas or stresses. In a sense the site of the birth
trauma learned to cope with the initial primary trauma and in
some way, as body memory, that area may have an expectation
or fear of further trauma. |

Figure 5Y: The prebirth labour lie, pressure and physical impacts
during the passage through the pelvis create predisposition
to somatic schemas. A womb surround drawing from a Natalistic
Art Workshop |
The
side of the labour lie holds stress and physical and emotional
stress cause a degree of muscular tightening and contraction.
Habitual contraction on one side of the body will cause the
head to tilt slightly to that side; the shoulder on that side
to drop; the torso to compress on the one side causing the
body to curve; and the leg on the more tense side to contract
and actually become shorter. The birth lie may actually be
seen in slightly distorted and drooping features on one side
of the face over the other. In this way, the entire body responds
to the initial birth trauma and the unique pattern forms in
which many later traumas will be interpreted and stored by
the body.
When there is an incident of possible
injury, like falling off a bike or slipping on the ice, it
is common to have the side of the birth lie try to protect
the person from the impact of the fall. Over a lifetime, the
side of the birth lie often has had more physical injuries
than the other side.
A person who is a right lie will often
experience the traumas of birth, like pushing in a hard long
labour, in the right side of the head or the right shoulder.
The body schema of right-sided lie is a simple model of a
straight forward uncomplicated right sided lie birth posture.
As with other life events, people and their births are idiosyncratic
and theories and models generally serve at best only as guidelines
to reflect upon when watching and listening to someone's experience.
A right sided lie who has a forceps impact on the left side
of the face or got the left shoulder caught can have a compound
left sided lie. Here much of the body may be torsioned to
the right and a shoulder or a portion of the face may be contracted
in a manner reflecting the left side assault. |
 |
|
TRANSMARGINAL
EXPERIENCE OF BIRTH
It is unfortunate that so few realize
that tiny helpless infants can actually be waiting to die
because of the degree of pain being inflicted on them in the
crushing, constricting annihilation of birth. The infant locked
in the container of birth may simultaneously experience a
significant deprivation of oxygen and thus have the terror
of suffocation added to the intolerable torture of being crushed.
Lake, 1966, allows: |
There is no doubt in the mind of several
patients that they had already passed the limit of tolerance
of pain during this descent, in the second stage of labour.
They had already lost all trust in the world into which
they were being thrust out. They would much rather have
been annihilated on the way. (pp. 626)
|
|
During the intolerable burden of birth,
the infant can feel, "I am dying. Why is she doing this
to me? What have I done wrong to deserve this?" In the
midst of a life/death crisis the prenate contemplates, "
For my very life, I have to fight to get out of here, or go
all the way back to there." The infant cannot make sense
of why the all-powerful and all nurturing universe of mother
would betray him with such brutality. Pain, logic and naive
innocence weave a rationale of self-blame. Lake (1979a) portrays
the vulnerable infant trying to make sense of a contracting
uterus which feels like a crushing assault: |

Figure 5Z: The crushing vaginal passage: from Grof (1980). |
"It must be something that
I have done wrong." It is too difficult to blame "the
other". A profound guilt arises that "I got myself
into this mess. It was all right. Then all this started
after one of my mischievous kicks. Instead of just getting
the expected mild reaction, all hell was let loose and the
world as I knew it is coming to a violent or a sticky end.
And it's all my fault." (p.10)
|
At certain points in birth the baby may even feel as if death
is imminent and unavoidable. Numbing drugs can add to the
sense of hopelessness and impending death. The baby can also
feel the devastation of perceiving that the mother has died
-- "Why else would she give up like that?" This
is particularly true when drugs are used in birth. The infant
feels that the mother has given up and that she may be dying
or dead. A difficult birth can be quite cruel to a vulnerable
and innocent tiny child. |
 |
|
BIRTH
RAGE
There can be feelings of rage against
all the cruelty surrounding the transformation of birth. Indeed,
some children come out raging. One mother of a grown daughter
told me in reflection, "I have never seen her as angry
as she was when she came back from the nursery after birth."
Verny (1981) agrees, "Anger is another birth legacy we
all share. It is a widely accepted psychological principle
that pain produces anger and, since even the best births involve
pain, it is inevitable that all of us are left with a subconscious
residue of primal anger" (pp. 123-4). When being hurt
and betrayed it is natural to feel anger. When the overwhelming
hurt and betrayal and anger at birth become buried, they follow
as shadows through life.
If the initial anger of birth evolves
into life patterns they can become ways of expressing resistance
or needing freedom such as the birth metaphors of: "Being
headstrong," "No one is going to stop me,"
or "Fighting to get through", "Don't get in
my way," just to name a few. Projected birth rage and
indignation emerges as metaphorical expressions of violence
such as, "Who do they think they are to push me around,"
"Wanting to rap him in the head," "Knocking
some sense into their heads," or "Squeeze the life
out of the S.O.B." The rage of birth often evolves from
a sense of intrusion, invasion and violation. The art work
of Giger clearly expresses the violent rage of being violated
and invaded during birth (Grof, 1985). Emerson (1989) has
observed that, "many children with aggressive behaviours
also have birth traumas which involve an "overuse"
of medical interventions (e.g. using forceps or suction devices
when they may not be required, doing extensive postnatal and
paediatric examinations, etc.)" (p. 201). Later life
language elaborations for the anger against the invasive medical
interventions can come out as, "Get out of my face,"
-- all the penetrations to the infant's face directly after
birth; "Stick it to him," or "They're going
to stick it to me" -- deep heal lancing; "Shove
it down your throat" or "Don't make me gag"
-- suctioning; "Cut them off," -- cutting cord before
breathing has been established. One client of Janov's (1983)
acknowledged: |
Anger has been my lifelong defense.
It started in the womb as a means to stay alive. In fact,
that aggression was the only thing that kept me alive. I
fought and struggled to try to make myself understood at
birth - to make it understood that I was dying. (p. 20)
|
|
The anger occurs because the life threats
and pain and hurts feel like they are being senselessly inflicted.
Working through the intense anger of birth can be difficult,
because often, underneath that anger, are the terrifying memories
of the innocent infant-within who struggled against death
at birth. Farrant (1987) shares the insights of a man who
was working with the underlying causes of his nearly constant
feelings of anger which were coming out in the work setting.
As a result of a preverbal regression, the client says: |
I quickly
discovered it [the anger] in my own birth as I couldn't
barely breathe at all.... Every time I went into a deep
breathing state and a deep feeling state I soon got to the
point where I couldn't actually get my breath...it was absolutely
terrifying. I used to think I was dying....
I found it quite hard at first to
face that... I began to understand that maybe my difficulty
with breath may be related to some of the anger... That
was very helpful to me in my work. (p. 30)
|
|

|
|
BODY
MEMORY METAPHORS OF BIRTH
Generally the lasting traumas of birth
involve various assaults and threats which are later associated
with similar experiences. Due to body memory and the dynamics
of physical and emotional shock, when early experience is
at the root of later character traits and adult symptomology,
the particular conditions which were at play at birth will
often be, at least partially, expressed in the original physical
sensations of that birth, or will be coded in symbolic or
metaphorical expressions of the physical conditions of the
events of the birth. Hendricks and Hendricks (1987) allow:
"Clients who are replaying elements of birth trauma frequently
say they feel stuck. The word 'pressure' comes up in their
conversation, and they may use other metaphors such as 'jammed'
or 'can't get out'" (p. 234). These are psychological
metaphors which originate in, and reverberate, with early
physical conditions. They may be viewed as the psychophysiological
memory of birth (Janov, 1974). |
| The
metaphors of birth are not just the elaborations of surface
language, but can be intricately woven into the overall feelings
and behavioural dynamics of major life afflictions. For instance,
hopeless depressions or bouts of anxiety can have a wide range
of accompanying physical sensations and activities which when
can be looked at as accurately replicating aspects of birth.
A depressed person may use expressions like "My life isn't
moving," he may experience physical feelings of being crushed
and weighed down, he may have the desire to numb it all with
drugs and hope to escape by having someone else to pull him,
exhausted, lethargic and depressed out of it. In this kind of
depressed state there are birth elaborations expressed in emotions,
physical sensations, behaviours, symbols and metaphors. |

Figure 5AA:Natalism from the fifteenth century by Hieronymus
Bosch, from Grof (1980). |
| For
a person to be in this degree of depression, there would certainly
be current life and childhood issues at play which would need
to be explored and resolved, but the extent of potential birth
expression being presented implores the therapist to take into
consideration the possible causal factors of birth. Unfortunately,
medicine and psychotherapy have been remiss in exploring the
often vivid natal feelings and sensations associated with the
somatic component of anxiety and depression. Working as both
physician and psychotherapist, Lake (l979a) observed with endogenous
depressives: |
many of these deeply depressed patients
were experiencing physical symptoms. Feelings of heart strain,
breathing difficulties not related to bronchial pathology,
tightness round the chest, headaches and localised pains
that shifted. Nobody had ever explained what these might
be related to. Well, now we know. They are the remembered
physical concomitants of this phase of birth, resonating
because similar patterned events are obstructing this man's
forward momentum in life. And the typical feelings of worthlessness,
uselessness, irrational guilt and culpability, loss of competence
and power to make progress, which are incomprehensible as
adult responses to this constricting life situation, are
actually recalled as part of the experience of this stage
of labour, as soon as "reliving" it takes place.
I am often amused at the relative ease with which these
stubborn, silent men move into reliving their births.(p.
11)
|
|
Often, just giving permission to have
a birth regression or to make birth art or poetry will be
enough to allow a person to connect deeply with the pre-and
perinatal realm. Once healing contact has been made with birth
material there may be a reservoir of issues and connections
which flow down the therapeutic causeway. |
 |
|
LIFE
SCRIPTS OF BIRTH
As people work through birth material,
their understanding of the influence of birth becomes increasingly
more specific to the idiosyncrasies of their particular birth
experiences. Life scripts as a result of specific types of
birth experiences fall into general patterns. This can be
helpful but should not be referred to dogmatically. Different
birth stimuli can send distinctly separate messages: breech
births, head first births, long-drugged births; or quick elective
caesarian births. As groupings, these can be significant in
reflecting different imprints and affect one's expectations
later in life. Emerson (1987) explains: |
For example, caesarian babies are
more likely (as adults) to have rescue fantasies and to
rely on others to "help them through." Forceps
and induced infants are more likely to develop symptomatic
issues around intrusion and authority. Infants with prolonged
containment (during second stage labour) are more likely
to manifest claustrophobia. (p. 62)
|
 |
|
BIRTH
AS PROTOTYPE FOR TRANSITIONS
Birth is a beginning and birth is an ending.
Birth can imprint the messages for what people expect to take
place in their life surrounding closures and endings. The
experiences of birth can also set expectations for what is
anticipated with arrivals, opening up and coming into things.
Noble (1993) reports: |
For example, a patient who couldn't
quite make it out of the birth canal always sets up situations
in which he never quite finishes anything properly. Another
client who was lifted out by Caesarean section may never
let anyone else set the time for her arrival or departure.
Some people allow deadlines for work or study to creep up
until there is hardly any time left, then they mobilize
themselves into action. Memories of our labour may enable
some of us to work well under pressure and to channel aggression
into more subtle acceptable forms. (p. 127)
|
|
In creating art or birthing art, birth
issues that relate to beginnings and endings can find their
way into the work or the art process. Birth is life's most
dramatic metamorphosis from one environment to another, one
world to another, one way of interacting to another, one sensory
theatre to another, one way of giving and receiving to another,
one form of biology to another. All of these profound transformations
occur early in a person's life. It is therefore not surprising
that biological birth may be a prototypic influence on life's
subsequent transitions and rebirths, personally, socially,
politically, culturally. Hendricks and Hendricks (1987) suggest
that, as a legacy of a traumatic transition at birth some
people can, "feel rattled by rapid change. Since contemporary
life is fraught with rapid change, it is easy to see why some
clients can stay in a perpetual state of reliving their birth
traumas" (p. 234).
Hendricks and Hendricks (1987) continue
that as a result of the burden of the birth stresses surfacing
within them: |

Figure 5BB" The Power of the devouring birth canal has
found many forms of expression in myths, art and personal and
social beliefs; Thirteenth century Florence; from Grom (1980). |
Common physical experiences and symptoms
appear in those clients replaying perinatal issues. They
tend to have histories of respiratory distress or illness,
such as strep throats, bronchitis, allergies, chronic colds.
Breathwork will often elicit tremendous congestion or mucous
discharge. Stress or energetic situations tend to create
nausea with headaches, dizziness, or head pressure. Clients
who have been heavily anaesthetized will tend to get sleepy
in stressful situations. The body is often extremely rigid
(ie., one woman who had steely skeletal muscles had a forceps
delivery so gruelling she had been administered last rites)
or extremely flaccid over a rigid core. A head torque to
one side or the other will often appear in those clients
who were delivered by forceps. (p. 234)
|
|
For making natalistic art work I often
have the client lying on a large, (in effect, relatively womb-size),
piece of paper. The massive drawing allows a sense of being
present within a womb. Movement patterns, feelings, sensations
and issues of birth will be presented to the client who is
lying down, breathing, and focusing on the body and being
contained by this womb-size piece of paper. |

Figure 5CC: Fifteenth century Pisa; from Grofn(1980). |
 |
|
RESOLVING
THE FEELINGS OF BIRTH
At times it is difficult and even overwhelming
for adults to face these feelings, which are really decades-old
memories. It is no wonder that the vulnerable infant, originally
going through these "absolutely terrifying" near-death
experiences, had to split off and bury them. Birth feelings
can have a high valence of emotion when they surface in therapy.
For some, direct abreaction or primalling may be too overwhelming.
Art work can be a more palatable approach
for those not at ease with the intensity of birth primals.
It is also true that individuals conversant with birth primals
have found that natalistic art expression does facilitate
emotional release. They have found that, when used with deep
feeling expressive work, the use of art has advantages; it
can progressively reduce overwhelming material; it clarifies
preverbal issues; and it greatly assists the client separating
from and letting go of long habituated birth feelings. The
repatterning value of artistic expression has been surprising
to some who have done most of their birth work through deep
feeling regression.
Resolving the latent feelings and patterns
of birth can be quite freeing. Life-long issues that have
been there, since birth, can be released and transformed.
Because birth material represents core issues with strong
emotional force, working through them can effect significant
and fundamental changes in the psyche. In part, the person
can achieve noteworthy transformation because the very foundations
through which many later experiences were filtered are being
examined and reformed. Janov (1983) allows: |
The important thing to understand
about prototypic behaviour is that it is a memory of the
beginnings of neurosis. All the later elaborations and manifestations
can ultimately be traced back to those beginnings. That
is why the resolution of neurosis must involve a return
to the originating prototype. (p. 50)
|
|
In whatever form the person returns to
birth memories they do so to sort through the primary core
of later life issues. Anger and fear are only two of many
adult feelings left from the early turmoil of birth.
As a result of the reverberations of birth
the person may also carry conflictive feelings of confusion,
hopelessness, numbness, hurt, rejection and loneliness, among
others. These initial and varied birth feelings become the
kaleidoscope which interprets and views the greater world.
Habituated birth feelings can be obstacles which the person
trips over and can become walls and barriers unto themselves.
There are many varied experiences of birth and many diverse
feelings in response to those birth experiences. Similarly,
over the years people create many different types of walls
or castles out of their original birth feelings. Lake (1979a)
explains: |
There are as many variations here
as people. Sometimes the forceps are put on and rotation
and extraction are re-enacted with vivid detail as to where
the steel dug in. The marks reappear. At times they knew
they were stuck and would have to be helped out; at others
they deeply resent "unnecessary" interference.
The re-enactment of birth by Caesarian section is varied.
A finger in the mouth turns the head and they are dragged
out backwards. People's reaction to being "Caesars"
is not unlike being a "Forceps". Sometimes they
say "Well--I've done as much as I can--someone's got
to get me out" and they are grateful. Or they are still
gamely struggling: "If only you'd left me to it. I
could have got out." Or, "You stopped me. I never
got born properly--you baby-snatcher, I've never had the
achievement of birth." These people have a greater
tendency to regress to inter-uterine states, psychologically,
philosophically and religiously, because they have never
gone through that half-way point of giving up inter-uterine
attachments and deciding to live towards the outside world.
(p. 11)
|
 |
|
RESOLVING
CORE ISSUES
The importance of understanding the compounding
and reinforcement of birth trauma by childhood experience
is emphasized by fact that the resolution of major or core
life issues often returns a person to foundational early stresses.
Similarly, birth feelings which surface in therapy are often
interwoven with later childhood trauma which needs to be explored
for full resolution of the adult issues. Life problems and
patterns which seemed to be worked through therapeutically
for childhood content, but which still persist as unresolved
and problematic material may well be worth exploring for perinatal
content. The dynamic also applies to clients who repeatedly
return to birth material but cannot get full relief of feelings
and symptoms. There may be childhood wounds intricately linked
to birth, awaiting resolution. Psychotherapeutically, it is
important to recognize that birth content in the psyche rarely
exists as independent and isolated issues.
In the therapeutic returning to birth
the person re-experiences aspects of the birth events. The
initial interpretations of the birth events have been played
through so many times that connections and insights may leap
out at the person. In some cases, insights come over a period
of days, weeks or months. Because a birth regression may have
much non-verbal expression, it is helpful to talk about the
regressive experience and its meaning after the person returns
to a verbal mode.
A significant advantage of using art work
as the means of birth regression, or in conjunction with other
forms of birth regression, is that the expressions and content
of the art work remain intact. When the person is no longer
in the birth regressed state, the message expressed with the
art work is still vividly present and does not slip away as
emotions and memories recede. As the process of therapy unfolds
over months, the birth regression art can be returned to,
to gain additional insights in understanding the tentacles
of birth. As other therapeutic issues arise, the person also
has the birth art to help them make sense of how the birth
pains have been carried through life. It can be valuable for
a person to place into context the legacy of birth feelings
and traits. |
 |
-
|
- To book clinical work or
mediation call (416)469-4764
|
|
|